iSAYSO
Contribute

Auckland Council contracts design out the very competition that drives sharp prices.

Share on FacebookShare on XInteractive reader

Auckland Council contracts design out the very competition that drives sharp prices.
Now, in my second term, I’m convinced Auckland Council doesn’t have an income problem, we have a spending problem.
Yet Council keeps asking ratepayers to choose between paying more rates for more services or paying less for fewer.
It never offers the obvious third option, which is getting more for what we already pay.
Watching the P27 contract renewal up close and talking with contractors who’ve tendered for the work, I’ve pieced together where much of that cost comes from and what I believe we can do to get more from existing rates levels.
Auckland Council spends over $6 billion a year with suppliers. Its own direction to staff says procurement should buy “the right thing, at the right scale, at the right time”, with a clear view of whole-of-life cost.
The P27 renewal of its Full Facility maintenance Contracts, worth more than $2 billion over 10 years, shows how far practice has drifted from those principles.
Four flawed management choices drive cost.
• No internal benchmark. Council no longer delivers any of this work itself. Without in-house cost data, we have no independent check on contractor pricing or margins. We are a buyer without a reference price.
• Asset rules that load capital cost into contract price. Contracts require modern vehicles, current equipment, uniforms and Council branding. Council says terms must run at least eight years so contractors can depreciate new plant. Ratepayers fund that depreciation in full but own none of the assets. Fully depreciated, well-maintained equipment, the main source of sharp pricing in the trades, is excluded by design.
• Entry thresholds that shrink the field. Minimum turnover and staffing requirements screen out new and small firms before price is considered. In the small contracts half of the hybrid model, 143 suppliers applied, and 74 remained by the time results reached elected members.
• Evaluation that sidelines price. Price is weighted at 60%, but only for bids scoring at least 50 on every non-price attribute. For bids that miss that bar, price counts for nothing.
Each rule has an arguable rationale: visibility, reliability, risk. But they remove the two groups most likely to undercut incumbents, established operators with paid-off plant and equipment, and hungry newcomers. The result is less price tension and higher costs.
What should change:
• Specify plant and machinery condition and performance, not asset age or appearance.
• Replace blanket thresholds with graduated entry. Small contracts open to new firms, scaling up with performance.
• Assess price for every compliant bid first.
• Keep a small in-house delivery capability as a cost benchmark.
• Use shorter, staggered contract terms to restore regular competition.
Council’s own procurement principles already point this way. The P27 contracts should follow them.
I’ve been carrying this message and a bag full of supporting information from office to office, up and down Council corridors, like a vacuum cleaner salesman, advocating for the change we need if we’re serious about getting our next long-term plan budget under control.