iSAYSO
Contribute

Public Service Commission declines broad justice administration investigation at this stage

Share on FacebookShare on XInteractive reader

The Public Service Commission has responded to Tracy Lynch’s complaint concerning alleged failures in justice administration, record integrity, complaint handling and leadership oversight.

The Commission says the information currently available does not provide a sufficient basis for the broad systemic investigation requested. It considers the responsible agencies and specialist oversight bodies better placed to examine the individual matters first.

This response does not determine whether the underlying allegations are correct. The Commission says it could reconsider if significant new information points to a wider systemic integrity issue or concerns about chief executive performance or conduct.

The official-information component remains separate: the Commission says those requests will be considered under the Official Information Act, with relevant parts potentially transferred to other agencies.

We are publishing this response to document how the complaint has been handled and what remains unresolved.

 

Kia ora Tracy,

 Thank you for your correspondence dated 30 September 2026 and 1 October 2026.  You have raised concerns about record integrity, complaint handling, inter-agency coordination and administrative decision-making across several justice and related agencies. You have also asked the Public Service Commissioner to take several specific actions.

 

We have considered the information you provided against the Public Service Commission’s When We Investigate framework. Our response to your requests is set out below.

 

Preservation of records

The Commission will retain and manage the information it holds in accordance with its legal and information-management obligations.

However, the Commission does not hold or control records belonging to Ministers, courts, the Ministry of Justice or other agencies. It therefore cannot direct those entities to preserve their records through this complaints process.

If you are concerned about particular records, you may wish to write directly to the entities that hold them, identifying the records, relevant dates and reasons for your request.

 

Requests for official information

Your requests for information about systemic errors, complaint handling, registry accuracy, performance measures, audits and reviews will be considered separately under the Official Information Act 1982 (OIA).

The Commission can respond only in relation to information it holds. If another agency holds information covered by your request, the relevant part may be transferred to that agency. We will advise you of any transfer.

You may also make separate, clearly defined requests directly to the agencies most likely to hold the information. If you are dissatisfied with an agency’s response, including a refusal, delay, extension or charge, you may complain to the Ombudsman.

We note that information held by agencies about particular, named, individuals may be subject to Privacy Act considerations.

 

Independent review and findings

We have carefully considered your request for an independent review. On the information currently available, the Commission does not consider it is best placed to undertake the wide-ranging review proposed.

The matters raised involve individual administrative, regulatory and court-related issues across several entities. Examining them would require detailed consideration of agency files, statutory decisions, court records and agency-specific processes. The agencies responsible and relevant specialist oversight bodies are better placed to establish the facts in the first instance.

The information provided does not currently demonstrate that the individual matters have a common cause or arise from a single systemic integrity failure. This does not mean the concerns are unimportant.  Rather, that the entities concerned should first have an opportunity to consider and respond to the matters within their responsibilities.

For the same reasons, the Commission is not able to make findings on the underlying allegations. Our assessment is limited to whether there is a sufficient basis for the Commission to begin an investigation.

 

Corrective action and leadership accountability

The Commission does not currently have a sufficient basis to require a corrective action plan or assess the performance or conduct of a public service chief executive.

If an agency’s consideration identifies errors or weaknesses, that agency will be best placed to determine what corrective action is required. It would also generally be appropriate for the chief executive of the entity to have an opportunity to consider and respond to concerns about their agency before the Commission considers getting involved.

The Commission may reconsider its position if significant new information emerges, indicating a systemic integrity issue or a matter concerning chief executive performance or conduct.

 

Timeframes and other options

We note your requested timeframes for acknowledgement and a response timetable. These are not statutory timeframes for the assessment of a complaint. Any official information request will be managed within the timeframes set by the OIA.

You may wish to provide each of the agencies concerned with a concise account of the matters concerning it, supporting records, and the outcome you are seeking. You could ask for the matter to be considered through the agency’s complaints process and for a written response addressing your concerns.

If you remain dissatisfied after giving the agency a reasonable opportunity to respond, you may be able to complain to the Ombudsman.

The Ombudsman can consider complaints about the administrative actions and decisions of many public sector entities, as well as responses to official information requests. The Ombudsman cannot review court or tribunal decisions and may not have jurisdiction over every matter raised.  Information about making a complaint to the Ombudsman in relation to government agencies can be found here: Complaints about government agencies | Ombudsman New Zealand

There may also be specialist complaint, appeal or review processes for particular issues.  The agency concerned should be able to explain any available review rights.

 

Conclusion

As noted above, your requests for information about systemic errors, complaint handling, registry accuracy, performance measures, audits and reviews are most appropriately considered separately by the relevant agencies under the OIA.

The Commission recognises that the other matters raised may be significant for the people concerned. However, the information currently available does not provide a sufficient basis for the Commission to undertake the broad systemic investigation requested.

The agencies concerned and their relevant, specialist, accountability bodies are better placed to examine the individual matters and consider any appropriate remedy in the first instance. The Commission could reconsider its position if those processes identify significant new information pointing to a wider systemic integrity issue or a matter concerning chief executive performance or conduct.

 

Ngā mihi,

 

Enquiries Team

īmēra: [email protected]

Public Service Commission Te Kawa Mataaho

www.publicservice.govt.nz | www.govt.nz

 

From: F Q <[email protected]> 
Sent: Thursday, October 1, 2026 2:13 AM
To: C Luxon <[email protected]>; Enquiries <[email protected]>
Cc: P Goldsmith <[email protected]>; N Mckee <[email protected]>; Contactus <[email protected]>; Records <[email protected]>
Subject: CORRE 2026-0801-Formal complaint WRTC JUSTICE 001 — Justice administration and leadership oversight

 

This email was sent from someone outside of Public Service Commission. Please take extra care.

 

Dear Prime Minister and Public Service Commissioner,

Please find attached my formal WE REVIEW THE CROWN complaint concerning reported failures in justice administration, record integrity, access to court processes and leadership oversight.

I request an independent assessment, preservation of relevant records, and a reasoned response identifying responsibility and corrective action. Please also confirm whether these concerns will be examined within the Ministry of Justice’s current Performance Improvement Review.

The complaint contains a separate Official Information Act request. Please register and process that component separately from the substantive complaint.

For the Public Service Commission, please refer this correspondence to the Commissioner. For the Ministry of Justice, please bring it to the attention of Secretary for Justice Andrew Kibblewhite.

Please acknowledge receipt within five working days, provide the complaint reference and responsible officer, and propose a substantive response timetable within ten working days. These are requested service periods; the information request remains subject to the applicable statutory requirements.

The case examples identify concerns requiring verification. This complaint seeks administrative and leadership accountability and does not ask for interference in judicial decisions.

Please reply to this FARQ email address and copy [email protected].

Yours faithfully,

Tracy Lynch
WE REVIEW THE CROWN
NOT A LAWYER