REQUEST FOR INVESTIGATION AND REVIEW – To Chief Ombudsman
REQUEST FOR INVESTIGATION AND REVIEW
Under section 28 of the Official Information Act 1982
To: The Chief Ombudsman
From: Tracy Lynch
Email: [email protected]
Date: 6 November 2026
Respondent: Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet — Cabinet Office
References: OIA-2026/27-0225 and OIA-2026/27-0309
Decision under review: Letter dated 4 November 2026, signed by Rachel Hayward, Clerk of the Executive Council, together with the earlier decision of 12 October 2026.
1. Nature of the application
I request an investigation and review under section 28 of the Official Information Act 1982 concerning the Cabinet Office’s decisions to refuse access to requested information and the adequacy of the searches undertaken.
My request concerns the identification, preservation, verification and disclosure of existing official records relating to the Crown, the Sovereign in right of New Zealand, and the instruments, offices and statutory powers through which constitutional authority is exercised.
I do not ask the Cabinet Office to create a constitutional opinion or documents that do not exist.
I seek verification that the Cabinet Office has undertaken reasonable searches, correctly applied the Official Information Act, and maintained the records required of a public office.
2. Evidence disclosed by the Cabinet Office
In its letter dated 4 November 2026, the Cabinet Office disclosed a table describing searches undertaken through its iManage electronic records system.
That table records that several searches returned more than 500 results, while other searches produced no documents considered relevant.
The Cabinet Office further acknowledged that officials relied upon their experience and general knowledge when identifying potentially relevant records.
The disclosed table does not establish whether all reasonably identifiable repositories, custodians, record classifications, or alternative search methods were considered.
I request that the Ombudsman examine the underlying search methodology and determine whether reasonable efforts were undertaken before the section 18(e) refusals were issued.
3. Application of section 18(e)
Section 18(e) permits refusal where a document alleged to contain the requested information does not exist or, despite reasonable efforts to locate it, cannot be found.
The Cabinet Office’s response does not distinguish, for each refusal, between a document established not to exist and a document that could not be found after reasonable searching.
This distinction is material to assessing whether the statutory refusal ground was properly applied.
I request that the Ombudsman examine the evidence supporting each refusal, including the search records, custodians consulted, relevant repositories and any decisions to discontinue or narrow searches.
4. Statutory duties
Section 5 of the Official Information Act establishes the principle of availability, subject to the grounds for withholding or refusing information provided by law.
Sections 12 and 13 address requests made with due particularity and the obligation to provide reasonable assistance.
Section 18B requires an agency contemplating refusal under section 18(e) or 18(f) to consider whether consultation with the requester would assist in reformulating the request.
Section 17 of the Public Records Act 2005 requires public offices to create and maintain full and accurate records of their affairs in accordance with normal, prudent business practice and to maintain public records in an accessible form.
I do not assert that the absence of a particular search log necessarily constitutes a breach of section 17. I request examination of whether records of the relevant official activities were created and maintained as required.
5. Transfers to Crown Law
The Cabinet Office confirms that part of question 1 and questions 8–10 of my original request were transferred to Crown Law, with transfer correspondence issued on 21 and 24 September 2026.
I request examination of the scope and basis of those transfers, including whether the Cabinet Office separately determined the information it continued to hold.
I further request confirmation that the transferred questions have been properly identified and addressed by the receiving agency.
6. Matters requiring investigation
I request that the Ombudsman examine:
The adequacy and reasonableness of the Cabinet Office’s searches.
The evidence supporting each section 18(e) refusal.
Whether relevant records were overlooked because searches produced large result sets.
Whether the Cabinet Office considered consultation under section 18B.
The records documenting the transfers to Crown Law.
Whether relevant recordkeeping concerns warrant referral to the Chief Archivist under section 28(6).
Whether additional existing information should be released.
7. Remedy sought
I request a determination as to whether the decisions under review were lawful and reasonable.
Where appropriate, I seek recommendations for further searches, reconsideration of refusals, disclosure of existing responsive information, and clarification of the grounds relied upon.
I also request that relevant search records, correspondence, transfer records, decision records and associated metadata be preserved while this matter is examined.
I ask to be informed of the outcome and reasons for the Ombudsman’s determination.
8. Supporting documents
The principal supporting document is the Cabinet Office response dated 4 November 2026, reference OIA-2026/27-0309.
The earlier correspondence dated 15 September, 21 September, 24 September, 29 September, 12 October and 14 October 2026 should also be considered where available.
Yours faithfully,
Tracy Lynch
[email protected]
Begin forwarded message:
From: Information [DPMC] <[email protected]>
Date: Nov 4, 2026 at 12:31 PM
To: F Q <[email protected]>
Subject: Your OIA request – Response[UNCLASSIFIED]
Kia ora
Please find attached a letter regarding your recent OIA request.
Ngâ mihi
Ministerial Coordinator
Ministerial Services
Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet
The information contained in this email message is for the attention of the intended recipient only and is not necessarily the official view or communication of the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet. If you are not the intended recipient you must not disclose, copy or distribute this message or the information in it. If you have received this message in error, please destroy the email and notify the sender immediately.
The information contained in this email message is for the attention of the intended recipient only and is not necessarily the official view or communication of the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet. If you are not the intended recipient you must not disclose, copy or distribute this message or the information in it. If you have received this message in error, please destroy the email and notify the sender immediately.