iSAYSO
Contribute

Electoral integrity – outstanding independent verification

Share on FacebookShare on XInteractive reader

Subject: Electoral integrity – outstanding independent verification

Dear Electoral Commission,

Thank you for the material provided.

Having reviewed the disclosure, I accept that the Commission has extensive internal controls for enrolment processing, duplicate detection, roll cleansing, returned mail, deceased-elector information, transaction checking and quality assurance. 

Electoral_OIA_Disclosure_Evidence_Pack_2026.pdf

The remaining issue is narrower:

where is the independent evidence that those controls operated effectively across the electoral process as a whole?

The disclosed material itself recognises duplicate records, incorrect merges, incorrect dormancy and other errors requiring correction. It also shows that monthly quality assurance is sample-based. Those controls are important, but the existence of a control is not the same as independent proof of its effectiveness. 

Electoral_Integrity_Audit_Report_v0.03_with_Evidence.pdf

I therefore ask the Commission to identify the independent assurance evidence for:

duplicate and deceased-elector reconciliation;

enrolment changes and audit trails;

unresolved exceptions at roll closure;

apparent multiple-vote reconciliation;

implementation and effectiveness testing of Auditor-General/PwC recommendations;

ballot-box custody, sealing, transfer and receipt;

preliminary and official-count reconciliation; and

final certification and sign-off.

For each relevant audit or review, please identify:

who conducted it, its terms of reference, scope, testing methodology, sample size, exclusions, findings, remediation, and who independently verified that the remediation worked.

If no independent end-to-end audit has been undertaken, please state that expressly.

I also request that the Commission consider initiating, or asking the appropriate independent body to undertake, an independent end-to-end electoral integrity audit.

This is not an allegation of fraud or invalidity. It is a request for verification.

The issue is straightforward:

A documented control is not the same as an implemented control, and an implemented control is not the same as a control independently demonstrated to be effective. 

Electoral_Integrity_Audit_Report_v0.03_with_Evidence.pdf

Please also preserve all records relevant to these assurance questions pending resolution of this request.

Yours faithfully,

Tracy Lynch
We Review the Crown / iSAYSO.net