OIA — Fiscal cost of Crown litigation, evidential assurance and self-represented litigants
I seek information under the Official Information Act 1982 concerning the fiscal consequences of litigation involving Crown agencies and the financial burden transferred to individuals who are required to represent themselves.
This request follows correspondence with the Ministry of Justice concerning self-represented litigants and the economic value of litigation work undertaken personally.
The Ministry has advised that the Accessible and Affordable Justice programme does not currently encompass the impact on individuals of personally bearing the time, expense and procedural burden associated with undertaking their own litigation work.
This raises a broader fiscal question for Treasury.
Significant public expenditure is incurred through Crown and government litigation, including expenditure by or associated with government departments, enforcement agencies, Crown Law, Crown solicitors, external counsel, investigators, experts, disclosure processes and court administration.
At the same time, individuals opposing those publicly funded agencies may be required to personally undertake extensive disclosure review, factual investigation, legal research, evidence preparation, drafting and court appearances because they cannot afford continuing professional representation.
Where the State funds one side of litigation but provides no equivalent means by which an individual can fund the necessary work required to test, defend or challenge that litigation, there is also a legitimate fiscal and access-to-justice question as to where those costs are intended to fall.
I therefore request the following information for the period 1 January 2016 to the date searches are completed.
1. Fiscal analysis
Please provide all Treasury reports, advice, briefings, Cabinet material, aide-mémoires, memoranda or other substantive analysis concerning the fiscal cost of litigation undertaken by or on behalf of Crown agencies.
Please include analysis concerning unnecessary, avoidable, unsuccessful, withdrawn, discontinued or prolonged litigation where held.
2. Evidential sufficiency and litigation cost
Has Treasury undertaken or received any analysis of the fiscal consequences of proceedings being commenced or continued where there are subsequently identified issues concerning:
(a) evidential sufficiency;
(b) disclosure;
(c) accuracy of material facts;
(d) reliability or verification of evidence;
(e) statutory authority or jurisdiction;
(f) procedural compliance; or
(g) decisions subsequently withdrawn, reversed, quashed, dismissed or otherwise not sustained?
If yes, please provide that information.
If no such analysis has been undertaken or received, please confirm that expressly.
3. Crown litigation assurance
What fiscal, assurance or accountability mechanisms exist to ensure public money is not spent commencing or continuing litigation without adequate evidential and legal foundations?
Please identify any standards, policies, Cabinet directions, Treasury guidance, investment or expenditure controls, reporting requirements, audit mechanisms or performance measures applicable to this issue.
4. Costs transferred to individuals
Has Treasury assessed the economic cost transferred from the Crown to individuals who must personally defend or bring proceedings involving publicly funded agencies?
This includes unpaid time and personally incurred expense associated with:
analysing disclosure;
investigating facts;
obtaining and organising evidence;
researching law;
preparing pleadings, affidavits and submissions;
corresponding with government agencies and counsel;
obtaining expert or professional assistance;
travel and other litigation disbursements; and
attending court.
Please provide any information held.
Please also identify whether Treasury has considered the fiscal consequences of leaving those costs with the individual where the proceeding is subsequently withdrawn, dismissed, struck out, reversed, quashed, unsuccessful or materially affected by evidential, disclosure or procedural deficiencies.
5. Self-represented litigants
Has Treasury assessed the fiscal or economic consequences of self-representation caused by the inability to afford private legal representation?
Has Treasury considered whether the absence of adequate financial assistance for litigation work undertaken personally by such individuals creates costs elsewhere in the justice system?
Has Treasury considered whether a person who is required to undertake substantial litigation work against a publicly funded agency should have access to an allowance, reimbursement, grant, indemnity, litigation-assistance fund, costs mechanism or other form of public financial assistance?
If so, please provide all relevant records.
If no such work has been undertaken, please confirm that expressly.
6. Government funding or reimbursement mechanisms
Please identify every current or historical government mechanism known to Treasury by which an individual may obtain public funding, reimbursement, compensation, costs, grants or other financial assistance to meet the reasonable cost of personally bringing, defending or participating in litigation involving a government or Crown agency.
For each mechanism, please identify:
(a) its statutory, regulatory, administrative or policy basis;
(b) the administering agency;
(c) eligibility criteria;
(d) whether it applies before, during or only after proceedings;
(e) whether it permits recovery for the individual’s own time and labour;
(f) whether it permits recovery of expert, research, disclosure, travel or other litigation expenses;
(g) whether it applies where proceedings are withdrawn, dismissed, struck out, reversed, quashed or unsuccessful; and
(h) any applicable rates, limits, scales or caps.
If there is no general mechanism by which an individual who cannot afford legal representation can obtain funding to personally undertake necessary litigation work against a publicly funded agency, please state that expressly.
7. Unfunded liability and subsequent recovery
Has Treasury considered whether the absence of an available funding mechanism causes individuals to seek recovery of those costs later through:
court costs;
compensation;
damages;
restitution;
counterclaims;
judicial review proceedings;
complaints or statutory remedies; or
subsequent civil proceedings?
I am seeking existing Treasury analysis of the fiscal consequences of this issue, not advice about any particular case.
Please provide any relevant records.
8. Legal-aid expenditure
Please provide Treasury advice concerning the increase in legal-aid expenditure and the additional Budget 2026 funding for legal-aid cost pressures.
In particular, please provide analysis identifying the underlying causes of increasing expenditure and any assessment of whether avoidable Crown litigation, disclosure failures, evidential deficiencies, delay, repeated hearings or other conduct by public agencies contributes to those costs.
9. Accessible and Affordable Justice programme
Please provide Treasury’s involvement in, advice concerning, or fiscal analysis of the Accessible and Affordable Justice programme.
Please identify what outcomes, performance measures or fiscal savings Treasury expects from that programme.
Please also identify whether the programme has considered direct financial assistance, reimbursement or recognition of litigation work personally undertaken by people unable to afford representation.
10. Verification before public expenditure
Has Treasury considered whether agencies exercising investigation, enforcement, prosecution or litigation functions should be required to demonstrate documented evidential verification or evidential sufficiency before substantial public expenditure is incurred?
If so, please provide that material.
If not, please state that expressly.
11. Agency-specific information
Please include information held concerning these issues in relation to:
Ministry of Justice;
New Zealand Police;
Ministry for Primary Industries;
Inland Revenue;
ACC; and
Crown Law.
12. Who ultimately bears the cost
Finally, please provide any Treasury analysis addressing who is expected to bear the economic cost where:
(a) a Crown agency has publicly funded investigative, legal and litigation resources;
(b) the affected individual cannot afford equivalent professional representation;
(c) the individual must perform the necessary litigation work personally in order to defend their position or challenge the Crown decision; and
(d) no existing funding mechanism is available to meet that cost.
If Treasury has undertaken no analysis of that question, please confirm that expressly.
I am not asking Treasury to determine the merits of any individual proceeding.
The purpose of this request is to establish what system-level fiscal controls exist over the expenditure of public money on Crown litigation, what mechanisms exist to prevent unsupported or inadequately verified proceedings from generating unnecessary public and private costs, and what provision the Government has made for the corresponding economic burden imposed upon individuals required to defend or challenge Crown action.
Where Treasury does not hold requested information but believes another agency does, please apply the transfer provisions of the Official Information Act as appropriate.
Where no information exists, please state that expressly rather than substituting general policy information.
Please identify the business units consulted, repositories searched, search terms used where recorded, and the officials or functions responsible for determining the scope of the searches undertaken.
Regards,
Tracy Lynch
F.A.R.Q.
NOT A LAWYER