iSAYSO
Contribute

Ministry of Justice’s OIA 135539 response dated 25 September

Share on FacebookShare on XInteractive reader

Please see attached FARQ’s response to the Ministry of Justice’s OIA 135539 response dated 25 September 2026.

FARQ’s position is that the Ministry has not answered the request made on 28 August 2026. The original request concerned whether any statutory, regulatory, court-costs, compensation, reimbursement, grant, administrative, or other mechanism permits financial recognition for litigation work personally undertaken by self-represented litigants, and if not, what decision or policy basis explains that absence.

FARQ asks the Ministry to either correct and complete OIA 135539, or confirm expressly that it considers the 25 September 2026 response complete. If the Ministry maintains that position, FARQ intends to place the matter before the Ombudsman.

The key unresolved issue is whether individuals who must personally undertake litigation work, including against publicly funded agencies, are denied meaningful financial recognition by statute, policy decision, administrative practice, historical default, or because the issue has never been properly considered.

******

Dear Ms Noyce,

Thank you for the Ministry’s response dated 25 September 2026, reference OIA 135539.

I have now reviewed the response carefully against my request of 28 August 2026.

The Ministry has not answered the central question I asked.

My request was specifically about financial assistance, reimbursement, costs or other economic recognition for litigation work personally undertaken by self-represented litigants.

I was not merely asking whether the Ministry has a standalone policy programme concerning self-represented litigants.

I asked whether any statutory, regulatory, court-costs, compensation or administrative mechanism presently permits a self-represented litigant to recover reasonable payment for the necessary litigation work they personally undertake, and, if not, whether the Ministry has considered establishing such a mechanism.

The response provided under OIA 135539 substitutes a different set of questions and then answers those instead.

That is not a complete response to the request actually made.

The Ministry’s letter does, however, make several important statements.

It confirms that:

the Ministry does not have a standalone work programme specifically focused on self-represented litigants;

no record has been identified showing that the absence of such a programme resulted from a specific work-programme decision;

the Ministry has identified no further material concerning the financial and procedural burden beyond the material previously released under OIA 134631; and

the impact on individuals of personally bearing the time, expense and procedural burden identified in my request is currently not part of the Accessible and Affordable Justice programme.

Those statements require clarification.

There are existing legal mechanisms that recognise litigation costs, including costs available to self-represented parties in civil proceedings and costs that may be awarded in criminal proceedings.

For example, current court rules expressly recognise a “party acting in person” within civil costs regimes.

The criminal jurisdiction also contains specific statutory costs mechanisms. The Criminal Procedure Act 2011 separately permits costs orders for significant procedural failures, including failures relating to the Criminal Disclosure Act 2008, and expressly preserves the operation of the Costs in Criminal Cases Act 1967. (New Zealand Legislation)

Accordingly, before the Ministry can say it has fully addressed my request, I require confirmation of what was actually checked.

Please provide a corrected response addressing the following.

1. Financial assistance or payment for self-represented litigation work

Does any existing statutory, regulatory, court-costs, compensation, reimbursement, grant, administrative or other mechanism permit a self-represented litigant to receive financial recognition for litigation work personally undertaken?

Please identify every mechanism located by the Ministry.

For each mechanism, please identify:

(a) its legal basis;

(b) whether it applies to civil, criminal, family, judicial review or other proceedings;

(c) whether it applies before, during or only after proceedings;

(d) whether it permits recovery for the person’s own time and labour;

(e) the rate, scale or method of calculation;

(f) what expenses or disbursements may be recovered; and

(g) the circumstances in which payment may be refused.

If no broader mechanism exists, please state that expressly.

2. The legal basis for the absence of assistance

If there is no general mechanism by which a person unable to afford private legal representation can receive financial assistance to conduct necessary litigation personally, please identify whether that absence results from:

(a) an express statutory prohibition;

(b) an express policy decision;

(c) an administrative decision;

(d) a Cabinet or ministerial decision;

(e) historical practice;

(f) the absence of any policy consideration at all; or

(g) some other basis.

I specifically seek the record establishing where, and by whose authority, the present position was determined.

If there is no such record, please state that expressly.

3. Verification of the Ministry’s response

Please confirm whether the Ministry considers its response of 25 September 2026 to be a complete response to the actual questions contained in my email of 28 August 2026.

If it does, please explain how each numbered question in the 28 August email was answered.

Please also confirm:

(a) what business units were consulted;

(b) what records repositories were searched;

(c) what date range was searched;

(d) what search terms were used, if recorded;

(e) whether officials responsible for civil costs policy were consulted;

(f) whether officials responsible for criminal costs policy were consulted;

(g) whether officials responsible for legal aid were consulted;

(h) whether officials responsible for the Accessible and Affordable Justice programme were consulted; and

(i) whether the officials carrying out the searches were provided with the actual questions contained in my 28 August email.

4. Civil self-represented litigants

Please identify all information held by the Ministry concerning the policy basis for permitting successful self-represented civil litigants to recover costs for acting in person.

Please include relevant policy papers, Rules Committee material held by the Ministry, briefings, advice, Cabinet material, ministerial correspondence and implementation records.

This is directly relevant because it demonstrates that the legal system already recognises that litigation work personally undertaken by a self-represented person may have monetary value.

5. Criminal defendants

Please identify what financial recovery is available to a self-represented criminal defendant where:

(a) a charge is withdrawn;

(b) a charge is dismissed;

(c) there is no case to answer;

(d) the prosecution is unsuccessful;

(e) disclosure obligations are materially breached; or

(f) another significant procedural failure causes the defendant unnecessary cost.

Section 364 of the Criminal Procedure Act expressly permits a court to make costs orders for significant procedural failures and provides that such an order may be made on the application of the defendant. (New Zealand Legislation)

Please therefore identify how those provisions interact with a self-represented defendant’s own time, labour and expenses.

6. Access to justice and publicly funded opponents

Please confirm whether the Ministry has assessed the situation where an individual is required to litigate against or defend proceedings brought by a publicly funded body such as:

New Zealand Police;

Ministry for Primary Industries;

Inland Revenue;

ACC;

another government department; or

the Crown represented through Crown Law or Crown solicitors.

Those agencies can draw upon publicly funded investigators, legal teams, Crown prosecutors, external counsel, experts and administrative resources.

The individual may simultaneously be unable to afford professional representation and may therefore have to undertake personally the disclosure analysis, evidence preparation, legal research, drafting and court appearances necessary to test the agency’s case.

Has the Ministry assessed how that imbalance is intended to be addressed?

If yes, please provide the records.

If no, please state that expressly.

7. Proceedings affected by evidential or procedural deficiencies

Please identify whether the Ministry has considered financial assistance, reimbursement or recovery for individuals who have incurred substantial self-representation costs where proceedings are subsequently:

withdrawn;

dismissed;

struck out;

unsuccessful;

materially affected by disclosure failure;

materially affected by factual error;

materially affected by lack of evidential sufficiency; or

materially affected by procedural unfairness.

Again, if no such work has been undertaken, please confirm that expressly.

8. Refusal grounds

Where information requested above does not exist or cannot be found despite reasonable efforts, please identify the applicable provision of the Official Information Act.

Where information is not held by the Ministry and the Ministry has reason to believe another agency holds it, please address the transfer provisions of the Act.

Please do not substitute a general policy explanation for a statutory refusal.

This matter is now significant because the issue is not theoretical.

Individuals are required to incur substantial personal expense defending or challenging publicly funded agencies.

If the Government has determined that those individuals are not to receive meaningful financial assistance for litigation work they must personally undertake, I am entitled to know:

By whose authority was that position determined, what evidence supported it, what policy analysis was undertaken, and where is the record?

If nobody has actually made that decision, that also needs to be stated clearly.

Please treat this correspondence as a request to correct and complete OIA 135539, not as a new OIA request.

If the Ministry maintains that its response of 25 September 2026 is complete, please provide that position expressly so that I may place the matter before the Ombudsman together with the original request and the Ministry’s response.

Regards,

Tracy Lynch
F.A.R.Q.
NOT A LAWYER

 

 

 

 

On Sep 25, 2026 at 4:04 PM, <[email protected]> wrote:

 

Tēnā koe Tracy

 

Please find attached the Ministry’s response to your request of 28 August 2026.

 

Ngā mihi,

 

Communications and Ministerial Services | Corporate Services

Ministry of Justice | Tāhū o te Ture
Justice Centre | 19 Aitken Street, Wellington (6011)

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

justice.govt.nz

 

 

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> 
Sent: Monday, 31 August 2026 2:16 pm
To: ‘F Q’ <[email protected]>
Subject: Further request (ref: 135539)

 

Tēnā koe Tracy

 

Thank you for emailing the Ministry of Justice (the Ministry).

 

We acknowledge receipt of your request under the Official Information Act 1982 (the Act).

 

This has been forwarded onto the our team member to respond to.

 

The Ministry may publish the response to your request on our website, you can expect that if your OIA is to be published that this will take place at least 10 working days after the response has been sent you. Your name and any other personal information will be withheld under Section 9(2)(a) (protect the privacy of natural persons) of the Act. If you do not want the response to your request published on the Ministry’s website, please contact us on receipt of this email.

 

You can expect a response by 25 September 2026.

 

Ngā mihi nui,

 

Ministerial Services

 

 

Communications and Ministerial Services | Corporate Services

Ministry of Justice | Tāhū o te Ture justice.govt.nz

 

 

From: F Q 
Sent: Friday, 28 August 2026 12:15 pm
To: [email protected]
Cc: Records 
Subject: Re: Response to your request for information (our ref 134631)

 

Subject: OIA 134631 — Separate Issue: Payment for Work Undertaken by Self-Represented Litigants

Dear Ms Noyce,

I write separately regarding a specific issue arising from the material released under OIA 134631.

The Ministry’s documents recognise that self-represented litigants undertake substantial work in preparing and conducting proceedings and may face significant procedural disadvantage compared with represented parties.

OIA_134631 – Lynch – Appendix 1.pdf

The Ministry also recognises a “justice gap” affecting people who cannot afford private representation but do not qualify for publicly funded legal assistance. The measures discussed in the released material focus principally on providing lawyers, duty lawyers, legal aid, community law services or other assistance.

OIA_134631 – Lynch – Appendix 1.pdf

However, I can identify no mechanism in the material released by the Ministry under this OIA which provides payment to a self-represented litigant for the necessary litigation work that person performs personally.

That distinction is important.

A represented litigant may incur lawyer’s fees for obtaining and analysing disclosure, preparing evidence, researching law, drafting pleadings and submissions, corresponding with other parties and attending court. Depending on the proceeding and outcome, some legal costs may ultimately be recoverable.

A self-represented litigant may undertake substantially the same necessary work personally, sometimes over months or years, but the documents released to me identify no equivalent hourly rate, daily rate, costs scale, allowance or reimbursement mechanism for that person’s labour and time.

This is particularly significant where self-representation is not simply a personal preference but occurs because a person:

cannot afford continuing legal representation;

does not qualify for legal aid;

has already incurred substantial legal fees;

cannot obtain suitable representation; or

must personally defend proceedings which are subsequently discontinued, dismissed, unsuccessful or shown to have involved material procedural or evidential deficiencies.

Accordingly, please answer the following as a separate and specific issue:

1. Does any statutory, regulatory, court-costs, compensation or administrative mechanism presently permit a self-represented litigant to recover reasonable payment for the necessary litigation work personally undertaken in preparing and conducting their proceeding?

If yes, please identify the mechanism, its legal basis and the method by which payment is calculated.

2. If no such mechanism exists, please confirm that expressly.

3. Has the Ministry considered establishing an hourly, daily or scale-based allowance for necessary litigation work undertaken personally by a self-represented litigant?

4. Has the Ministry considered such an allowance specifically where the person successfully defends a prosecution or other proceeding that is withdrawn, dismissed, struck out, unsuccessful, or materially affected by disclosure failure, factual error or procedural unfairness?

5. Has the Ministry considered whether the absence of such a mechanism creates an inequality between represented litigants, whose professional legal work may have recoverable monetary value, and self-represented litigants performing necessary litigation work themselves?

This question is distinct from legal aid.

I am asking about the economic recognition of the work actually performed by the litigant personally.

The Ministry’s own material acknowledges that effective access to justice requires more than the technical ability to enter a courtroom. Internal Ministry material records that the right of self-representation may become effectively “hollow” if a person cannot properly engage with and participate in the legal process.

OIA_134631 – Lynch – Appendix 1.pdf

Please therefore provide a direct response to each numbered question rather than referring generally to existing legal-aid or court-information services.

If the Ministry has undertaken no policy work on this issue, please state that clearly.

Regards,

Tracy Lynch

 

 

 

On Aug 28, 2026 at 7:49 AM, <[email protected]> wrote:

Tçnâ koe Tracy

 

Please find attached the Ministry’s response to your request of 27 July 2026.

 

Ngâ mihi,

 

Communications and Ministerial Services | Corporate Services

Ministry of Justice | Tâhû o te Ture
Justice Centre | 19 Aitken Street, Wellington (6011)

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

justice.govt.nz

 

 

From: f.a.r.q 
Sent: Thursday, 6 August 2026 7:05 pm
To: [email protected]
Cc: Records 
Subject: Re: Clarification email for your request for information (our ref 134631)

 

Thank you for your email.

I provide the following clarification of my request.

Timeframe

Please search for information held by the Ministry from 1 January 2016 to the date the searches are completed. Where a policy, framework or document was created before 1 January 2016 but remained current, was relied upon, or informed Ministry work during this period, please include it.

Scope

My request is directed to the Ministry’s system-wide policy responsibilities regarding access to justice and self-represented litigants. It is not limited to any particular court, tribunal, jurisdiction or individual proceeding.

I seek information relating to self-represented litigants across proceedings administered or supported by the Ministry, including civil, criminal, family, tribunal, appellate and judicial review matters, particularly where individuals are required to engage with one or more publicly funded agencies.

The request includes any policies, strategies, work programmes, briefings, Cabinet papers, reports, research, internal advice, file notes, meeting records, emails, or other documents concerning:

  • self-represented litigants and access to justice;
  • the procedural and resource burden experienced by self-represented parties;
  • mechanisms to recognise or address that burden;
  • any consideration or development of policy in these areas; and
  • records concerning the preservation of this correspondence and associated records under the Public Records Act 2005.

For clarity, I am not seeking legal advice or comment on the merits of any individual proceeding. I am seeking existing information held by the Ministry concerning its policy functions and responsibilities.

I note your acknowledgement that the request for clarification was made outside the seven-working-day period contemplated by section 15(1AA) of the Official Information Act. This clarification is provided to assist the Ministry to process the request efficiently and is not intended to replace or restart my original request of 27 July 2026.

Please confirm the Ministry’s recorded date of receipt and the current statutory due date for responding.

Thank you. I look forward to your response.

 

Tracy Lynch

 

 

 

On 6 Aug 2026, at 17:38, [email protected] wrote:

Tçnâ koe Tracy

 

Thank you for your request of 27 July 2026, requesting information under the Official Information Act 1982 (the Act). You requested:

 

Please advise:

  • Whether the Ministry has any policy, strategy, or work programme relating to self-represented litigants and access to justice.
  • Whether the Ministry has considered the procedural and resource burden placed upon self-represented parties involved in proceedings with multiple publicly funded agencies.
  • Whether any mechanism exists to recognise or address the substantial time, expense, and procedural work undertaken by self-represented litigants in order to obtain disclosure, prepare evidence, and participate effectively in legal proceedings.
  • Whether the Ministry has prepared or holds any briefings, reports, Cabinet papers, policy advice, or other documents relating to these issues.
  • Whether this correspondence and all associated records, including internal emails, file notes, assessments, and decision-making records, will be preserved in accordance with the Public Records Act.

For the avoidance of doubt, I am not seeking legal advice or asking the Ministry to comment on the merits of any individual proceeding. I am seeking information about the Ministry’s policy responsibilities and any existing frameworks relevant to these matters.

 

Section 12(2) of the Act requires that information sought be specified with due particularity. This means the Ministry of Justice (the Ministry) must be reasonably able to identify the information requested.

 

As currently framed, your request is broad, and it is unclear what information and records fall within scope. Accordingly, under section 15(1AA) of the Act, we are seeking clarification of your request. Could you please confirm:

  1. The timeframe for the information you are seeking. For example, information from the most recent calendar year up to date, the last three calendar years, or between particular dates.
  2. Whether you are seeking information about these issues in relation to a particular court, tribunal, jurisdiction or type of proceeding.

 

We would appreciate receiving your clarification by 10 August 2026.

 

We apologise that our request for clarification is late, however, the Ministry is keen to provide you with a fulsome response and would appreciate your clarification.

 

If you are not satisfied with the way your request is being managed, you have the right under section 28 of the Act to complain to the Ombudsman. The Ombudsman can be contacted by telephone on 0800 802 602, by email at [email protected], or via the Ombudsman’s online complaint form.

 

Ngâ mihi,

 

Image removed by sender.

Communications and Ministerial Services | Corporate Services

Ministry of Justice | Tâhû o te Ture
Justice Centre | 19 Aitken Street, Wellington (6011)

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

justice.govt.nz

 

 

From: F Q <[email protected]> 
Sent: Monday, 27 July 2026 4:11 pm
To: [email protected]; Records <[email protected]>
Subject: Access to justice policy and self-represented litigants

 

 

I write following correspondence with The Treasury regarding access to justice and the procedural burden experienced by self-represented litigants.

The Treasury has confirmed that the Ministry of Justice is the government lead on access-to-justice policy and that any policy work relating to self-representation would be led by the Ministry. Treasury also advised that its role is limited to providing fiscal and economic advice where appropriate.

Accordingly, I seek clarification of the Ministry’s position.

Please advise:

Whether the Ministry has any policy, strategy, or work programme relating to self-represented litigants and access to justice.

Whether the Ministry has considered the procedural and resource burden placed upon self-represented parties involved in proceedings with multiple publicly funded agencies.

Whether any mechanism exists to recognise or address the substantial time, expense, and procedural work undertaken by self-represented litigants in order to obtain disclosure, prepare evidence, and participate effectively in legal proceedings.

Whether the Ministry has prepared or holds any briefings, reports, Cabinet papers, policy advice, or other documents relating to these issues.

Whether this correspondence and all associated records, including internal emails, file notes, assessments, and decision-making records, will be preserved in accordance with the Public Records Act.

For the avoidance of doubt, I am not seeking legal advice or asking the Ministry to comment on the merits of any individual proceeding. I am seeking information about the Ministry’s policy responsibilities and any existing frameworks relevant to these matters.

If any part of this request is more appropriately dealt with under the Official Information Act 1982, please treat it as a request under that Act.

I look forward to your response.

Kind regards,

Tracy Lynch