iSAYSO
Contribute

Subject: OIA-2627045 / OIA-2627076 — Request for reconsideration and particularisation of refusal

Share on FacebookShare on XInteractive reader

Another good example of the run around we get given from Crown Law. 

 

Subject: OIA-2627045 / OIA-2627076 — Request for reconsideration and particularisation of refusal

Dear Mr Neild,

Thank you for Crown Law’s response dated 24 September 2026 concerning OIA-2627045 and OIA-2627076.

I have now reviewed that response carefully, including the UK House of Commons Library briefing by David Torrance, The Crown and its Constitution, to which Crown Law directed me.

The response does not resolve the central issue. It appears to place the requested information into three materially different categories:

information Crown Law says is not held and would require the creation of new legal advice;

information Crown Law says is already publicly available; and

information Crown Law says is held but protected by legal professional privilege.

Those are different propositions under the Official Information Act 1982 and should be identified separately against the individual questions asked.

I therefore ask Crown Law to reconsider and particularise its response as follows.

1. OIA-2627045 — reliance on section 18(g)

Crown Law records that the transferred portions of my 15 August request concern:

the identity and meaning of expressions including “Britain”, “British Crown”, “Crown”, “Sovereign”, “King”, “New Zealand” and “Crown in right of New Zealand”;

the provenance and acquisition of sovereignty, including what precisely was acquired and the legal act of acquisition; and

the reach and continuity of the claimed authority, including its application to non-signatories, later generations, the present Crown and persons born in New Zealand. 

OIA-2627045; OIA-2627076 – Response to Tracy Lynch, 24 September 2026(10463083.4).pdf

Crown Law then states that this is a request for legal advice and therefore for the creation of new information, and refuses the request under s 18(g) because the requested information is said not to be held. 

OIA-2627045; OIA-2627076 – Response to Tracy Lynch, 24 September 2026(10463083.4).pdf

For clarity, I am not asking Crown Law to create a new constitutional opinion.

I seek existing official information already held by Crown Law, including existing:

legal records;

memoranda;

policies;

manuals;

constitutional guidance;

practice material;

correspondence;

instruments;

authorities;

historical or constitutional analyses; and

other recorded or known information responsive to the questions asked.

The Ombudsman’s guidance on s 18(g) states that, before relying on that provision, an agency should make reasonable efforts to locate the information, and should be able to explain either the steps taken to locate it or the reasons it is not held. 

Accordingly, for each of the transferred subjects identified at paragraphs (a), (b) and (c) of Crown Law’s letter, please state:

whether Crown Law searched for existing responsive information;

what classes or repositories of information were searched;

whether responsive information was located;

whether Crown Law holds responsive information in existing legal advice or other records;

whether Crown Law’s position is that no existing record whatsoever is held addressing the particular matter; and

if responsive information is held but withheld for another statutory reason, identify that reason rather than treating the information as nonexistent.

The distinction is fundamental.

“We do not hold the information” and “we hold responsive material but will not release it because it is privileged” are not the same answer.

2. OIA-2627076 — Crown Law’s different refusal grounds

Crown Law correctly records that the 15 September request sought existing records concerning:

the meaning of “Crown” or “the Crown”;

the authority under which “King”, “the King” or “the Crown” is used as a legal actor in New Zealand proceedings;

the chain of authority from the Sovereign through the Governor-General, Ministers, Law Officers, Crown Law and prosecutors;

the instruments supporting that chain; and

the legal person or constitutional entity represented by “King” or “The King” in New Zealand court proceedings. 

OIA-2627045; OIA-2627076 – Response to Tracy Lynch, 24 September 2026(10463083.4).pdf

Crown Law then relies on both s 18(d), for information said to be publicly available, and s 9(2)(h), for information contained in privileged legal advice. 

OIA-2627045; OIA-2627076 – Response to Tracy Lynch, 24 September 2026(10463083.4).pdf

Please therefore identify, question by question, whether the responsive information is:

(a) not held;

(b) held and publicly available;

(c) held but withheld under s 9(2)(h);

(d) partly publicly available and partly withheld;

(e) held and capable of release; or

(f) held in another form or source.

At present Crown Law’s response does not permit me to determine which ground applies to which requested information.

3. The Torrance briefing does not answer the New Zealand questions asked

Crown Law relies on David Torrance’s The Crown and its Constitution as a publicly available source relevant to my request. 

OIA-2627045; OIA-2627076 – Response to Tracy Lynch, 24 September 2026(10463083.4).pdf

I have now reviewed that document.

It is a United Kingdom House of Commons Library research briefing. It is useful general constitutional background, but it does not appear to contain the information requested in significant parts of questions 1 and 6–10.

In particular, the briefing explains that the expression “the Crown” does not have a single, universally applicable meaning and discusses the Crown in several different constitutional capacities. It also discusses the development of distinct Crowns in separate Commonwealth realms.

That background reinforces the need for the identification I requested. It does not supply it.

I have located nothing in that briefing which identifies:

the precise legal person or constitutional entity represented by “The King” in a New Zealand criminal proceeding styled King v [Defendant];

whether that expression means Charles III personally, the constitutional office of Sovereign, the Sovereign in right of New Zealand, the Crown, the New Zealand Government, the executive, or the prosecuting authority;

the particular New Zealand statutory, prerogative, constitutional or other authority under which the King or Crown is used as a party in New Zealand proceedings;

the requested New Zealand chain from Sovereign through Governor-General, Ministers, Attorney-General/Solicitor-General, Crown Law/Crown Solicitor and prosecuting agency;

the individual commission, delegation, warrant, statutory provision or other instrument supporting each relevant link in that chain.

The Ombudsman’s guidance on s 18(d) states that the provision applies where the requested information is or will soon be publicly available, and that the discretion must be exercised reasonably in the circumstances of the particular request. 

Accordingly, if Crown Law continues to rely on s 18(d), please identify:

Request item → public document → page/section → proposition said to answer the request.

A publication concerning the general constitutional concept of “the Crown” is not, without more, a publicly available answer to the New Zealand-specific information requested.

4. The Torrance briefing also does not answer the sovereignty questions

The same briefing does not identify:

the legal entity said to have acquired sovereignty or governmental authority over New Zealand;

from whom or what that authority was acquired;

what precise authority was acquired;

the territory and persons over whom it was acquired;

the precise legal mechanism by which acquisition occurred;

the legal doctrine extending the resulting authority to non-signatories and later generations; or

the complete legal chain by which that asserted authority became vested in the present Crown in right of New Zealand.

Accordingly, that briefing cannot, by itself, constitute a publicly available answer to those parts of my request.

If Crown Law considers that the answers instead appear in other publicly available New Zealand statutes, cases, proclamations, constitutional instruments, historical instruments or other authorities, please identify those authorities specifically.

5. Section 9(2)(h) — identify the existence and scope of responsive material

Crown Law also states that, to the extent my request concerns legal advice “provided (or held)” by Crown Law, the material is withheld under s 9(2)(h). 

OIA-2627045; OIA-2627076 – Response to Tracy Lynch, 24 September 2026(10463083.4).pdf

That statement is significant because it indicates that responsive information may exist and be held.

I therefore request, without seeking disclosure of privileged legal advice itself:

identification of which numbered request items engage s 9(2)(h);

confirmation whether one or more responsive records exist;

whether each record is withheld in full or in part;

whether non-privileged factual, administrative, statutory, historical or constitutional material can be separated and released;

whether Crown Law holds non-privileged manuals, policies, commissions, appointments, delegations, warrants, practice material or instruments answering any part of the request; and

confirmation that partial release of separable information has been considered.

I do not ask Crown Law to waive legal professional privilege.

I ask Crown Law to distinguish the existence of responsive information from the question whether its substantive content may properly be withheld.

6. The central evidential question remains unanswered

The central question remains:

What existing official record states who or what acquired sovereignty or governmental authority in relation to New Zealand; from whom or what it was acquired; what precisely was acquired; over which people and territory; by what lawful mechanism; and through what constitutional or legal chain that authority became the authority exercised by the present Crown in right of New Zealand?

If Crown Law’s answer is:

“No existing record held by Crown Law sets out that proposition or chain,”

please say so expressly.

If the answer is:

“Responsive records exist, but they are withheld under legal professional privilege,”

please say so expressly and identify the request items to which that position applies.

If the answer is:

“The requested information is contained in publicly available authorities,”

please identify those authorities and the particular proposition each is said to establish.

Those answers are materially different and should not be conflated.

7. Clarification of the request

For the avoidance of doubt, I clarify the request as follows:

I seek existing information held by Crown Law at the date of my requests. Crown Law is not required to formulate a new legal opinion, undertake new historical research, or create a new constitutional analysis.

Where responsive information exists, please identify and provide it subject to any properly applicable withholding provision.

Where it does not exist, please say so.

Where it is publicly available, please identify the actual source and relevant portion.

Where it is privileged, please identify the applicable request item and the basis of the withholding without disclosing privileged content.

8. Requested schedule

Please provide a schedule in the following form:

Request item | Information held? | Record/source identified | Publicly available / released / withheld | OIA ground | Specific public authority or source

This will permit the decisions under ss 18(d), 18(g) and 9(2)(h) to be understood and, if necessary, reviewed.

9. Review before Ombudsman referral

I ask Crown Law to reconsider and particularise the 24 September response before I refer the matter to the Ombudsman.

Please also confirm expressly whether Crown Law maintains that it holds no existing non-privileged record identifying the legal chain from the asserted acquisition of sovereignty or governmental authority to the authority presently exercised by the Crown in right of New Zealand.

That is a question concerning the existence of official information. It does not require the creation of a new legal opinion.

Please keep all correspondence and clarification in writing.

Yours faithfully,

Tracy Lynch
for InLandsAirWater Counsel – Private Trust
We Review the Crown
[email protected]

 

 

 

 

 

Open attached document or media