iSAYSO
Contribute

Local Govt has got worse.

Share on FacebookShare on XInteractive reader

 

 

Taxpayers' Union Logo 
 

Hi Pete,

It’s really great when I can email our supporters about a campaign victory – especially in local government.

But this email is not about a victory.

In fact, it’s a major loss, and I need to apologise to you and the thousands of our supporters who have backed our efforts to protect ratepayers and improve governance at local councils.

The summary is this:

Thanks to last-minute changes to Simon Watts’ Local Government (Systems Improvement) Bill, the ability for Mayors and Councillors to demand information from council CEOs has been curtailed.

Despite Simon Watts telling the media that he has “strengthened” councillors’ rights to information, it is now in statute law that the final decision maker for what information councillors can and can’t see is not in the hands of the councillors themselves, but the council CEOs.

It’s a major blow. And a huge win for the likes of LGNZ and the council bureaucracies.

And it wasn’t what Local Government Minister Simon Watts had promised us. 

When our policy team received the wording for Mr Watts’ amendment at 5 pm last Monday, we immediately told the Minister’s office that there was a mistake.

His office had told us the amendment would remove the CEO’s decision-making power and allow councils to overrule officials blocking information – but the last-minute change did the exact opposite, strengthening the CEO’s power and removing the council’s ability to overrule them.

But by Tuesday afternoon, it was too late. Watts had passed the amendment in Parliament. And at 11 pm the next day (i.e. last Wednesday night) it passed the third (and final) reading in Parliament.

In a podcast I recorded on Thursday – literally just hours after the law passed – Simon Watts dismissed our concerns.

When I asked the Minister why he hadn’t even replied to our letters and communications pointing out the mistakes in his Bill (including the letter from our lawyers attaching expert advice sent back in May), Simon Watts literally said “You are not special“.

You are not special, Pete – says Mr Watts.

In fact, we’d been asking to meet (and record this podcast) for months. But his officials scheduled it for straight after the final passage of the laws we wanted to talk to him about.

I put that, rates capping, co-governance, and many of your questions directly to the Minister.

What do you think? Was I rude? Did I go too far? Watch the interview with Simon Watts here.

Simon Watts

As you’ll see, Minister Watts denies there is even an issue and didn’t seem to want to get into the details. 

The background

You’ll recall that for more than a decade the Taxpayers’ Union has campaigned to improve access to information for local council elected officials.

Since 2014, we have called for statutory law setting out that mayors and councillors have the same rights to information held within a council that directors have for a company. 

The common law (i.e. court-made law) is actually quite strong. It has a default right to information and puts the onus on the council to show that there was reason to believe information would likely be misused. 

But the law was being widely ignored. We would see examples every month of councillors having to use freedom of information law to seek basic information from their own councils.

That means that every day, council CEOs around New Zealand would block councillors from accessing information because it is “operational, not governance” information; “private”; or “commercially sensitive”.

So we were delighted when successive Local Government Ministers – first Simeon Brown, then Simon Watts – told us they’d fix it.

It wasn’t complex: councillors need a clear right to the information, without council officials acting as gatekeepers. You can read what we were asking for here.

But the proposed Bill put the chief executive in charge of deciding what information elected councillors were entitled to see.

We warned them!

We explained this problem to MPs in our submission to the Governance and Administration Committee in October (nearly a year ago). Our written submission is here, or you can watch that submission here.

Submission

We also reached out to the Local Government Minister Simon Watts’ office. 

But the warnings fell on deaf ears.

In May, we obtained independent legal advice from public law experts Franks Ogilvie, which confirmed our concerns: Simon Watts’ bill did the very opposite of what he said was intended. You can read that letter to the Minister and the legal advice here.

Watts made a bad law even worse 😕
 

The original bill was bad enough, but at least it included a provision that gave elected members (through the governing body) the power to override the chief executive.

But the last-minute changes removed that basic protection.

The Taxpayers’ Union will continue to fight to improve the governance, accountability and transparency of local government – even if it means we need to fight for a new law change.

Thank you for standing with us, and while I am sorry to have let you down here, we will not be giving up.

Yours sincerely,

Jordan Jordan signature
Jordan Williams
Executive Director
New Zealand Taxpayers’ Union

 

 

 

 

New Zealand Taxpayers’ Union · 117 Lambton Quay, Level 4, Wellington 6011, New Zealand 
This email was sent to [email protected]. To change your email preferences, click here. 
Authorised by the New Zealand Taxpayers’ Union, Level 4, 117 Lambton Quay, Wellington 6011.