FORMAL LETTER to TREASURY
This about the expenditure of a lot of money concerning the pandemic from the Treasury, without verified authority.
Gross expenditure- recoveries = net public cost – resulting Crown borrowing, without verified authority
FORMAL LETTER TREASURY
WE REVIEW THE CROWN / iSAYSO.net
FORMAL NOTICE — REQUEST FOR RECONSIDERATION, VERIFICATION AND ACCOUNTABILITY
Treasury Reference: 20260654
24 September 2026
To:
The Secretary to the Treasury / Chief Executive
The Treasury
1 The Terrace
Wellington 6011
Cc: Alastair Gilby, Unit Manager, Ministerial Advisory Service
Re: OIA 20260654 — COVID-19 expenditure, recoveries, Crown borrowing and public debt — failure to answer central verification questions
Dear Secretary,
1. Purpose of this letter
- I write following Treasury’s response dated 24 September 2026 to Official Information Act request 20260654.
- The response does not substantively answer the principal questions put to Treasury.
- Instead, Treasury has refused the request under s 18(d) of the Official Information Act 1982 on the basis that the requested information “is or will soon be publicly available”.
- That assertion now requires verification.
- Treasury is requested to reconsider its decision and identify, with precision, the records upon which it relies.
2. What Treasury was actually asked
- This was not a general request for information concerning COVID-19 expenditure.
- The request sought to establish the financial chain between:
authority → allocation → appropriation → actual expenditure → recoveries and offsets → residual Crown liability → borrowing → interest/public debt → audit and verification.
- Treasury was expressly asked whether it:
undertook, received or relied upon a consolidated reconciliation between COVID-19 expenditure, insurance or other recoveries, and resulting Crown borrowing.
- If no such reconciliation existed, Treasury was expressly requested to say so and identify the alternative record or control relied upon to assure itself that recoveries had been accounted for before the residual public cost was reported or financed.
- Treasury’s response does not answer that question.
3. Treasury’s published material does not resolve the issue
- Treasury’s own published material describes the COVID-19 Response and Recovery Fund as a funding envelope for budget management purposes, rather than an actual ring-fenced fund.
- Treasury records total COVID-19 response and recovery funding allocations of $70.4 billion.
- Treasury separately states that allocation, appropriation and expenditure are different concepts.
- Its published expenditure material records total actual/estimated expenditure for 2019/20 to 2021/22 of approximately $46.696 billion to $49.567 billion. Treasury further acknowledges that, where COVID initiatives were placed into existing appropriations, it cannot identify precise actual initiative-level expenditure and instead uses estimates based upon wider appropriation spending patterns.
- Treasury also records that:
- some funding was returned;
- some appropriated amounts exceeded fiscal impacts;
- some expenditure was expected to be offset by revenue or returned funding;
- tagged contingencies lapsed, were returned, or remained undrawn; and
- the amount appropriated and the expenditure incurred can differ from the amount recorded against the CRRF.
- Those matters make the requested reconciliation more, rather than less, important.
4. Verification required
- Treasury is requested to answer each of the following questions directly.
A. Consolidated reconciliation
- Did Treasury prepare, receive, maintain, review or rely upon any record reconciling:
gross COVID-related expenditure less recoveries, repayments, refunds, returned funding and other offsets = residual Crown cost → resulting borrowing/public debt?
- If yes:
- identify the record;
- identify its author;
- identify its date;
- identify the officials who reviewed it;
- identify who approved or relied upon it; and
- provide it.
- If no such record exists, state:
“Treasury holds no consolidated reconciliation between COVID-related expenditure, recoveries/offsets and resulting Crown borrowing.”
- Treasury should then identify precisely what alternative accounting, assurance or control process performed that function.
B. What was actually spent?
- Identify the verified total of actual Crown expenditure attributable to the COVID response.
- Distinguish:
- allocations;
- appropriations;
- actual expenditure;
- estimated expenditure;
- contingencies;
- transfers;
- returned funding;
- cancelled initiatives; and
- amounts continuing into later financial years.
C. What came back?
- Identify all material sums returned to, recovered by, reimbursed to or otherwise credited to the Crown in connection with COVID expenditure, including:
- returned appropriations;
- unused funding;
- loan repayments;
- tax recoveries;
- insurance recoveries;
- indemnity-related recoveries;
- contractual reimbursement;
- third-party recoveries;
- subrogation;
- refunds;
- clawbacks; and
- other credits or offsets.
- For each material amount, identify:
payer → recipient → amount → date → Crown account/entity → ledger treatment → ultimate application.
D. Net liability
- What was the final verified net Crown cost, after all such offsets and recoveries?
- Who calculated it?
- Who checked it?
- Who signed it off?
- Where is the supporting record?
E. Borrowing
- What Crown borrowing was undertaken because of the fiscal consequences attributed to the COVID response?
- For each material borrowing programme or decision relied upon for this purpose, identify:
- the statutory authority;
- the responsible Minister;
- the Treasury recommendation;
- the decision or instrument exercising that authority;
- the amount;
- the relevant dates;
- the purpose recorded contemporaneously; and
- the officials responsible for execution.
- Where Treasury relies upon s 47 of the Public Finance Act 1989 or another statutory provision, identify the relevant exercise of that authority and the record evidencing it.
F. Interest and financing cost
- Has Treasury calculated the financing or interest cost attributable to borrowing associated with the COVID fiscal response?
- If yes, provide that calculation and its methodology.
- If no such calculation exists, state that expressly.
G. Verification
- Identify the person, office or institution responsible for verifying:
- actual expenditure;
- returned or recovered funds;
- the residual fiscal cost;
- borrowing requirements;
- debt reporting; and
- the financial statements in which those amounts ultimately appeared.
- For each, identify the relevant verification, certification, reconciliation, audit or sign-off record.
5. “Publicly available” requires precision
- Treasury has relied upon s 18(d).
- The Ombudsman’s published guidance confirms that s 18(d) concerns information that is or will soon be publicly available.
- Accordingly, if Treasury maintains that the questions above have already been answered publicly, please provide for each question:
document title → page → paragraph/table → URL → precise information answering the question.
- It is not sufficient to refer generally to a webpage containing related subject matter.
- A record concerning funding allocations is not necessarily a record of actual expenditure.
- A record of actual expenditure is not necessarily a reconciliation to borrowing.
- An indemnity document is not necessarily evidence of a recovery.
- A forecast fiscal impact is not necessarily the final verified net public cost.
6. Authority and responsibility
- Please identify the names and official positions of the persons who were materially responsible for:
- recommending establishment and enlargement of the CRRF;
- approving material COVID fiscal decisions;
- authorising the relevant Crown borrowing;
- administering the borrowing;
- accounting for recoveries and returned funding;
- certifying the relevant Crown financial information; and
- independently auditing that information.
- This request is for officials acting in their official capacities and records establishing the responsibilities attached to those offices.
7. Lawfulness
- We are not asking Treasury simply to assert that the expenditure and borrowing were lawful.
- We request the recorded legal authority relied upon.
- For the material classes of expenditure and borrowing, identify:
the statutory provision → appropriation or other authority → decision-maker → contemporaneous decision record → financial transaction/reporting record.
8. Required response
- Please reconsider Treasury’s blanket reliance upon s 18(d).
- For each part of OIA 20260654:
- answer it; or
- identify the exact public information answering it; or
- identify the particular statutory ground relied upon for withholding/refusal; or
- expressly state that the requested record does not exist or is not held.
- Please do not substitute general explanatory material for the requested accounting and evidential record.
- The question is ultimately straightforward:
What was actually spent, what came back, what remained to be funded, what was borrowed as a consequence, who authorised it, and who independently verified that calculation?
- Those matters should be capable of being demonstrated from the Crown’s records.
Yours faithfully,
Tracy Lynch
We Review the Crown
iSAYSO.net
NOT A LAWYER
Please find attached the response to your request for information.
Kind regards,
Bradley Martin | Te Tai Ōhanga The Treasury
Ministerial Advisory Service
Strategy, Performance and Government ServicesStrategy and Executive Services Division, Enabling Services Group