Official Information Act Request — Meaning and Authority of ‘King’, ‘The King’, ‘Crown’ and ‘The Crown’
Dear Sir/Madam,
OFFICIAL INFORMATION ACT 1982 REQUEST
— WE REVIEW THE CROWN
We Review the Crown is undertaking a public-interest examination of the legal and constitutional authority represented by terminology used in New Zealand legislation, court proceedings and official decision-making.
This request seeks existing records and documents rather than legal opinion.
Please provide:
1. Any current policy, guidance, memorandum, legal guidance, constitutional guidance, manual, practice note or other record held by your agency that defines or explains the expressions “Crown” or “the Crown”.
2. Any record explaining whether, and in what circumstances, each of the following expressions has the same or a different legal meaning:
– “King”;
– “the King”;
– “King Charles III”;
– “His Majesty the King”;
– “Sovereign”;
– “the Sovereign”;
– “the Sovereign in right of New Zealand”;
– “Crown”;
– “the Crown”;
– “Crown in right of New Zealand”;
– “the Crown in right of New Zealand”; and
– “His Majesty the King in right of New Zealand”.
3. For each expression above, please provide any record identifying whether it denotes:
– the natural person Charles III;
– the office of King;
– the office of Sovereign;
– the Sovereign in right of New Zealand;
– the Head of State;
– a corporation sole or other legal personality;
– the New Zealand Government;
– the executive government;
– the State;
– the prosecuting authority;
– the Crown as a constitutional institution;
– the Crown as a legal entity; or
– some other person, office, institution or entity.
4. Please provide any record explaining whether the presence or absence of the definite article “the” changes the legal meaning of:
– “King” and “the King”; and
– “Crown” and “the Crown”.
5. Please provide any drafting guidance, court guidance, legislative drafting convention, style guide, practice note or other record explaining when “King” is used rather than “the King”, and when “Crown” is used rather than “the Crown”.
6. Any record identifying the legal person, office, institution or entity represented by “King” or “The King” when either expression appears as a party to a New Zealand court proceeding, including a criminal proceeding styled King v [Defendant] or The King v [Defendant].
7. Any record identifying whether the words “King” or “The King” on such court documents mean:
– King Charles III personally;
– King Charles III in his constitutional capacity;
– the Sovereign in right of New Zealand;
– the Crown;
– the New Zealand Government;
– the executive branch of government;
– the prosecuting authority; or
– some other legal person or entity.
8. Please identify the statutory, prerogative, constitutional or other legal authority under which “King”, “the King”, “Crown” or “the Crown” is used as a party, authority or legal actor in New Zealand court proceedings.
9. Please provide any record identifying the chain of authority by which proceedings brought in the name of King, the King, the Crown, or otherwise under Crown authority are authorised, including, where applicable, the relationship between:
King Charles III → Sovereign in right of New Zealand → Governor-General → Executive Council/Ministers → Attorney-General/Solicitor-General → Crown Law/Crown Solicitor → prosecuting agency or prosecutor.
10. Please provide any instrument, warrant, commission, delegation, appointment, Letters Patent, statutory provision, practice direction or other record relied upon as authority for any link in that chain.
11. Section 2(1) of the Constitution Act 1986 states:
“The Sovereign in right of New Zealand is the head of State of New Zealand.”
Please provide any records held explaining the legal meaning of the expressions:
– “Sovereign”;
– “the Sovereign”;
– “in right of New Zealand”; and
– “head of State”.
12. Please provide any records identifying what, legally, the Sovereign is sovereign of, over, or in respect of when described as “the Sovereign in right of New Zealand”.
13. Please provide any records explaining the distinction between:
– New Zealand as a sovereign State;
– King Charles III;
– the office of King;
– the Sovereign in right of New Zealand; and
– the Crown in right of New Zealand.
14. Please provide any records explaining the legal effect of the Constitution Act 1986 on the Crown and monarchy in New Zealand, including whether that Act:
– created a new Crown;
– continued an existing New Zealand Crown;
– altered the source of Crown authority;
– altered the constitutional position of the monarch; or
– restated or consolidated existing constitutional arrangements.
15. Please provide any records held concerning the constitutional continuity between Queen Elizabeth II and King Charles III following the death of Queen Elizabeth II on 8 September 2022, including the legal mechanism by which the office, powers and authority continued.
16. Please identify the current legal instrument establishing King Charles III’s New Zealand royal style and title and provide a copy of, or link to, the relevant proclamation or instrument.
For clarity, this request is not asking the agency to create a legal opinion.
Where an answer is contained in legislation, a proclamation, Letters Patent, Cabinet Manual provision, Crown Law guidance, departmental guidance, court practice material, legislative drafting guidance or another existing record, please identify and provide that record.
Where terminology is treated as interchangeable, please provide the record establishing or explaining that convention.
Where no responsive record exists for any question, please state expressly that no record is held, rather than substituting a general explanation.
Where information is withheld, please identify the specific withholding provision relied upon and the reasons for its application.
Electronic response is preferred.
Kind regards,
Tracy Lynch
We Review the Crown
iSAYSO.net
NOT A LAWYER