Office of the Health and Disability Commissioner
Dear Dr Goodwillie,
Thank you for your response dated 17 September 2026.
HDC has now confirmed that figures previously supplied were materially incorrect. In particular, HDC has corrected the total number of COVID-related complaints from 1,742 to 1,140, and the number of COVID-testing complaints from 75 to 51, describing this as an “error in collation.”
L-01169 Information Request_signed.pdf
Given the scale of those corrections, I now request the records necessary to establish how the original figures were produced, checked and authorised.
Please provide:
The source records, database extracts, reports, spreadsheets, working papers or calculations used to produce the original figures of 1,742 and 75.
The source records, database extracts, reports, spreadsheets, working papers or calculations used to produce the corrected figures of 1,140 and 51.
The precise database search, query, filters, coding fields or methodology used for each set of figures.
The name and role, or if necessary the position title, of each person who:
prepared the original figures;
checked or verified those figures;
reviewed the response; and
authorised release of the original figures.
The same information for the corrected figures.
The date on which the errors were first identified.
The record showing how the errors were identified.
All internal communications, notes, emails, memoranda or other records concerning discovery, discussion, checking or correction of the errors.
Any policy, procedure, quality-assurance process or verification standard applying to statistical information released under the Official Information Act.
Whether the incorrect figures were supplied to any other requester, agency, Minister, researcher, media organisation or other person, and if so, what corrective action was taken.
Whether, after discovery of these errors, HDC reviewed any other COVID-related complaint statistics for accuracy, and if so, the records and outcome of that review.
Please clarify the reference in the 17 September 2026 letter to a partial transfer from the Ministry of Health on 19 September 2026, including the correct date and the contemporaneous record establishing that date. The response is itself dated 17 September 2026.
I am not asking HDC to create new information or to provide opinion. I am seeking the existing records showing the provenance, verification, approval and correction of the figures released.
Please preserve all records relevant to this request, including database extracts, query logs, spreadsheets, drafts, emails, internal messages and approval records.
If any part is refused, please identify the specific information withheld, the statutory ground relied upon, and the public-interest considerations applied where relevant.
This request is made because HDC has itself acknowledged that materially incorrect official figures were previously released. The purpose of this request is to establish the verification process and chain of responsibility before any further step is taken.
Yours faithfully,
Tracy Lynch
iSaySo.net
Reference: TL1169CG
On Sep 17, 2026 at 8:33 AM, <Craig Goodwillie> wrote:
Dear Ms Lynch,
Please find our response attached x 3.
Note the information requires a password. Please confirm receipt to receive the password.
Regards
Dr Craig Goodwillie
OIA Team Leader
Office of the Health and Disability Commissioner | Te Toihau Hauora, Hauatanga
PO Box 245, Wellington 6140