When a government department or Crown action causes a legally recoverable financial loss, exactly where does the affected person send the claim,
WE REVIEW THE CROWN | FARQ
FARQ-TREASURY-INS-008
CROWN LIABILITY, COMPENSATION AND CLAIM PAYMENT PATHWAY
Official Information Act 1982 request | Insurance & Indemnity Evidence Register
Date
21 September 2026
To
The Treasury, New Zealand
From
Tracy | FARQ / We Review the Crown
Reference
FARQ-TREASURY-INS-008
Purpose
This request seeks the Crown-wide administrative and financial pathway that applies when a person or business alleges that a government department or Crown action has caused a legally recoverable loss. It is intended to identify the correct notification route, decision-maker, source of payment, indemnity or insurance arrangement, accounting treatment, and recovery process. It does not assume that liability exists in any particular case.
The Public Finance Act 1989 controls Crown guarantees and indemnities, including Ministerial and specified departmental authority. Treasury guidance also records that costs under certain guarantees or indemnities are met from departmental baselines and advised to the Secretary to the Treasury. The Crown Proceedings Act 1950 provides the statutory framework for specified civil claims against the Crown. This request seeks the operational records that connect those legal frameworks to an actual claimant pathway.
1. Crown-wide claim notification pathway
1. Please provide any current Treasury policy, instruction, guidance, manual, workflow or standard process identifying how a person or business is to notify the Crown of an alleged civil liability, compensable loss, property loss, contractual loss, economic loss or other claim for payment arising from departmental action or omission.
2. Identify whether a claim should first be sent to the responsible department, Treasury, Crown Law, the Attorney-General, the Ministry of Justice, an insurer, broker, loss adjuster, indemnity administrator, or another office, and identify the circumstances in which each route applies.
3. Identify any prescribed or recommended claim form, evidential requirements, time limits, limitation warnings, acknowledgement process, reference-number system, escalation process and review process.
2. Who decides liability and who authorises payment?
4. Identify the office or role responsible for deciding whether an alleged Crown liability is accepted, disputed, settled, referred for legal advice, or defended.
5. Identify the delegations, financial authorities, settlement thresholds or approval levels applying to departmental settlements, ex gratia payments, compensation payments and payments made under guarantees or indemnities.
6. Identify when Treasury, the Minister of Finance, Crown Law, the Attorney-General or another Minister must be consulted or approve a proposed payment or settlement.
3. Source of money and accounting treatment
7. For an accepted claim or settlement, identify the possible source of payment: departmental baseline, departmental or non-departmental appropriation, permanent legislative authority, Crown account, indemnity, commercial insurance, self-insurance or another mechanism.
8. Provide guidance identifying how such liabilities and payments are recorded in departmental accounts and, where applicable, the Financial Statements of the Government, including contingent liabilities, provisions, settlements, compensation, ex gratia payments and recoveries.
9. Identify the accounting treatment for a payment later recovered from an insurer, supplier, contractor, indemnifier or other third party.
4. Crown insurance, self-insurance and risk financing
10. Provide any current Crown-wide policy or guidance describing when the Crown or departments self-insure, purchase commercial insurance, rely on indemnities, or retain risk within departmental baselines.
11. Identify any central register, database or reporting mechanism held by Treasury for material Crown insurance policies, indemnities, guarantees, contingent liabilities, notified circumstances, claims, settlements or recoveries.
12. Where no central register exists, identify which office is responsible for knowing where these liabilities are recorded and how Treasury obtains information necessary for Crown financial reporting and fiscal-risk management.
5. Guarantees and indemnities
13. Provide current Treasury guidance implementing sections 65ZC to 65ZG of the Public Finance Act 1989, including the process for approval, recording, monitoring, payment and recovery under Crown guarantees and indemnities.
14. Identify how a third-party claim that may engage a Crown indemnity is notified, assessed and referred to the indemnified party and the Crown, and whether any claimant can notify Treasury directly that an indemnified risk may have crystallised.
15. Identify the process by which payments made under an indemnity are traced to the underlying event and any subsequent recovery from another person, insurer, supplier or contractor.
6. Civil claims and Crown Proceedings Act interface
16. Provide any Treasury-held guidance explaining the administrative steps taken when a threatened or filed civil claim against the Crown is received, including referral to Crown Law and identification of the appropriate defendant or department.
17. Identify how an agreed settlement or judgment under the Crown Proceedings Act 1950 is translated into an authorised Crown payment and which entity records the liability and payment.
18. Identify any distinction in the payment pathway between court-ordered damages, negotiated settlements, contractual payments, property loss, independent economic loss, ex gratia payments and statutory compensation schemes.
7. Verification: what must exist before the Crown pays or refuses?
For each pathway above, please identify the minimum record expected to exist before a claim is accepted, rejected or closed, including:
• the identity and delegated authority of the decision-maker;
• the factual material relied upon and how material facts are verified;
• legal or policy authority relied upon;
• financial approval and source of funds;
• reasons for acceptance, rejection or settlement;
• any insurer, indemnity, supplier or third-party recovery considered; and
• the record-retention requirement applying to the claim file.
8. Where Treasury says information is not held
If Treasury considers any requested information is not held, cannot be found, or does not exist, please do not provide only a bare statement to that effect. For each such item, please identify, to the extent recorded:
19. the searches undertaken and the systems, repositories and business units searched;
20. whether the relevant record was never created, was previously held and disposed of, was transferred, or cannot now be located;
21. the applicable retention or disposal authority where a record was destroyed or disposed of;
22. the agency, department or office believed to hold the information and whether transfer under section 14 of the Official Information Act will occur; and
23. where no central record exists, the office responsible for the underlying function and the mechanism by which Treasury obtains sufficient information for its statutory financial and fiscal responsibilities.
The absence of a record is not treated by this request as an automatic admission of liability. It will, however, be recorded as an evidential and recordkeeping issue where the surrounding statutory, accounting or administrative framework indicates that a record would ordinarily be expected.
9. Response format and preservation
24. Please answer each numbered item separately and provide the title, date and reference number of each document relied upon.
25. Where a document is withheld in whole or part, identify the specific Official Information Act provision relied upon and release the balance where reasonably practicable.
26. If another agency holds a requested record, please transfer the relevant part under section 14 rather than treating it simply as information not held by Treasury.
27. Please provide records electronically in searchable form where available.
28. Please preserve records relevant to this request, including registers, claim pathways, indemnity records, payment authorities, accounting instructions and referral protocols, pending completion of this request and any review.
Central question
When a government department or Crown action causes a legally recoverable financial loss, exactly where does the affected person send the claim, who verifies and decides it, who has authority to pay it, from what account or risk-financing mechanism is it paid, and where is the payment or recovery recorded?
Authority references
Public Finance Act 1989, ss 65ZC-65ZG – Crown guarantees and indemnities. Treasury, A Guide to the Public Finance Act (2026 edition), “Guarantees and indemnities”; Treasury Instructions 2024, cl 6.8.5. Crown Proceedings Act 1950, including ss 3, 6, 14, 17 and 24. These references identify relevant statutory frameworks; they do not predetermine liability in any individual case.