iSAYSO
Contribute

Re: The Treasury – Acknowledgement and clarification

Share on FacebookShare on XInteractive reader

Treasury was asked to account for the public-money trail behind MPI action

FARQ / We Review the Crown has formally asked Te Tai Ohanga The Treasury and the Minister of Finance to identify the financial authority, compensation pathways, insurance arrangements, indemnities, recoveries and accountability framework connected with disputed MPI action affecting farmers and primary producers.

The notice follows MPI’s refusal of information request FARQ-MPI-INS-003, which sought records about poultry and primary-producer losses, compensation claims, ex gratia payments, insurance, recovery arrangements and who ultimately bears financial loss when MPI action causes harm.

The Treasury notice makes clear that it is not asking Treasury to decide individual MPI complaints or court proceedings. Instead, it asks Treasury to identify the Crown financial framework: what public money is used, what appropriations fund MPI action, whether compensation or ex gratia payments are available, whether the Crown self-insures or recovers from insurers or industry bodies, and what assurance exists that spending is lawful.

The notice also raises wider public accountability questions about Government-Industry Agreements, Crown-funded litigation, poultry-sector concentration, and whether smaller producers may be differently affected by regulatory, biosecurity or enforcement action.

Treasury acknowledged the request and warned that the scope may be treated as too broad unless refined. FARQ replied that the breadth reflects the seriousness and spread of the issues, and that the central question remains simple: when MPI action causes verifiable loss, what compensation route exists, what is paid or declined, who bears the loss, and where is that expenditure or recovery recorded?

 

Faith,

The scope of this matter reflects the breadth and seriousness of MPI’s conduct. It is not a proper answer to describe the issues as “too broad” when they concern multiple MPI decisions, prosecutions, seizures, enforcement actions, and substantial losses allegedly imposed without verified evidence.

Several cases are presently proceeding through the courts despite serious questions about whether MPI possesses admissible evidence supporting the allegations. Continuing proceedings without first verifying the evidential foundation wastes public money, imposes substantial costs on the affected people, and risks serious miscarriages of justice.

These are not abstract policy questions. The central questions are straightforward:

Who held the statutory or delegated authority to make each material decision?

Who personally exercised that authority?

What evidence did that person examine?

What steps were taken to authenticate and verify that evidence?

What contemporaneous record documents that verification?

Who supervised or approved the resulting enforcement or prosecution action?

Who is accountable where no verification occurred, or where information was altered, contradicted, or presented without a proper evidential foundation?

Your own response must also be accounted for. Please identify:

Your full position and the capacity in which you wrote to me.

Whether you personally made the decision not to answer, or merely communicated a decision made by another person.

The name and position of the person who authorised or approved your response.

The statutory delegation, written authority, policy, or instruction relied upon.

The records and correspondence you reviewed before describing the matter as too broad or declining to answer it.

Every person or business unit you consulted before sending the response.

The precise statutory ground relied upon for refusing, limiting, or declining any part of the request.

A copy of the recorded reasons for that decision.

Confirmation of whether an authorised decision-maker verified the accuracy and lawfulness of your response before it was sent.

I recognise that an employee does not require separate statutory authority merely to send an email. However, if your communication conveys an official decision to refuse or limit a request, MPI must be able to identify the authorised decision-maker, the lawful ground relied upon, and the recorded reasons for that decision. Please state plainly whether you were the decision-maker or only its messenger.

If MPI considers the request extensive, that is a consequence of the number and nature of the matters requiring examination. It does not remove MPI’s obligation to identify the records it holds, provide reasonable assistance, consult on practical sequencing, and give a lawful and particularised basis for withholding or refusing each part.

If the relevant information is held across different MPI business units, the request should be divided internally and referred to the appropriate record-holders. Systemic or repeated failures cannot properly be converted into a procedural excuse for avoiding scrutiny.

These matters are directly relevant to existing and anticipated court proceedings. If MPI does not identify the relevant authority holders, decision-makers, verification processes, and records voluntarily, the affected parties may seek formal disclosure and, where permitted by the Court, summons the responsible individuals to give evidence under oath.

Accordingly, please provide:

the name, position, and delegation of each relevant decision-maker;

the name and position of each person who verified or approved the evidence relied upon;

the applicable statutory authority and internal policy;

the contemporaneous verification, approval, and decision records;

the evidential material actually before each decision-maker;

the chain of responsibility from investigator through to enforcement or prosecution approval; and

express confirmation wherever a requested verification, authority, or approval record does not exist.

MPI is now on notice of the alleged evidential and verification failures. If it nevertheless continues proceedings without addressing them, its decisions, records, use of public money, and the conduct of the responsible individuals may be placed before the courts and the appropriate oversight bodies. All available remedies, including disclosure, judicial review, costs, complaints, and applications concerning the admissibility or sufficiency of evidence, are expressly reserved.

The issue is no longer whether the request is inconveniently broad. The issue is whether MPI can demonstrate that coercive decisions and prosecutions were undertaken by properly authorised people, on verified evidence, through a documented and lawful process.

Please address that issue directly.

Yours faithfully,

Tracy Lynch
NOT A LAWYER
We Review the Crown
isayso.net

 

On Sep 22, 2026 at 4:23 PM, <Ministerial Services Inbox [TSY]> wrote:

 

Kia ora

 

Thank you for your request under the Official Information Act 1982, which was received on 14 September 2026. A response will be provided in accordance with the Act.  

 

Your request is broad in scope and is likely to be refused under section 18(f) of the Official Information Act as substantial manual collation would be required to provide the information requested.

 

As such, I would like to suggest refining your request, so we are able to make the proper considerations on the information you are seeking. We are happy for you to provide more specific detail in relation to the request. However, I recommend refining your request, for example by:

  • providing a timeframe for the information, and
  • limiting the scope to one aspect of the overall topic.

 

Please note that once you have amended or clarified your request, under section 15(1AA) of the OIA, the Ministry may treat your amended or clarified request as a new request that replaces the original request. This may lead to a new start of the statutory response period.

 

I look forward to hearing from you regarding the refinement of your request.

 

Kind regards

Nikki

 Dear Treasury and Hon Nicola Willis,

Please find attached our formal notice concerning MPI authority, compensation, Crown expenditure, insurance, indemnity, recovery and related Crown accountability issues.

The notice arises from MPI’s refusal of Official Information Request FARQ-MPI-INS-003 under section 18(h) of the Official Information Act 1982.

The substantive concern is now broader than that refusal.

We are seeking verification of the Crown financial and accountability trail, including:

  • the appropriations funding relevant MPI activity;
  • compensation and ex gratia expenditure;
  • insurance, indemnity and recovery arrangements;
  • Government-Industry Agreement and related financial instruments;
  • Crown exposure arising from poultry and other primary-production responses;
  • Crown Law and litigation funding connected with disputed MPI action; and
  • the assurance mechanisms by which expenditure is verified as falling within statutory authority.

We are not asking Treasury to determine the merits of individual MPI complaints or court proceedings.

We are asking Treasury and the Minister of Finance to identify the financial authority, funding structure, liabilities, recoveries and assurance framework applying to those matters.

The attached notice sets out the questions in full.

The MPI refusal giving rise to this escalation will be forwarded beneath this correspondence for completeness of the record.

Please acknowledge receipt and provide the relevant Treasury reference number.

Kind regards,

Tracy Lawyer
iSAYSO.net
We Review the Crown
NOT A LAWYER

 

 

 

On 22 Sep 2026, at 11:30, MPI Customer Enquiries Centre <[email protected]> wrote:

Kia ora Tracey

 

Thank you for your request for information.

 

MPI has previously discussed with you the difficulties created by requests that seek very large volumes of information across multiple subject areas and lengthy time periods. We have also encouraged you to submit more focused requests so that the information sought can be reasonably identified and assessed.

 

Despite this, your latest request contains around 25 separate questions, spans more than 16 years, and seeks information from different operational areas across MPI.

 

In the circumstances, MPI considers that this request forms part of a pattern of excessively broad requests which place an unreasonable administrative burden on MPI. Accordingly, on behalf of Michelle Morehu, Director Government Services, your request is refused under section 18(h) of the Official Information Act 1982.

 

You have the right to seek a review of this decision by the Ombudsman.

 

Kā mihi

 

Official Information Act team
Government Services | Public Affairs

Ministry for Primary Industries – Manatū Ahu Matua
Charles Fergusson Building, 38-42 Bowen Street | PO Box 2526 | Wellington 6140
Telephone: 0800 00 83 33 | Email: [email protected] | Web: www.mpi.govt.nz

 

 

From: F Q <[email protected]> 
Sent: Monday, 21 September 2026 8:01 am
To: MPI Customer Enquiries Centre <[email protected]>
Cc: Records <[email protected]>
Subject: OFFICIAL INFORMATION REQUEST – POULTRY / PRIMARY PRODUCER LOSSES, COMPENSATION AND CLAIM OUTCOMES

 

FARQ-MPI-INS-003

OFFICIAL INFORMATION REQUEST – POULTRY / PRIMARY PRODUCER LOSSES, COMPENSATION AND CLAIM OUTCOMES

To

Ministry for Primary Industries – Official Information

From

Tracy – FARQ / We Review the Crown

Date

21 September 2026

Reference

FARQ-MPI-INS-003

Purpose

Verify the loss, compensation, claims and payment record affecting poultry operators and other primary producers following MPI biosecurity/regulatory action.

 

Request

Please provide the following information under the Official Information Act 1982. This request is directed to the financial and administrative record. It does not assume that any particular MPI intervention caused industry consolidation or that compensation was payable in every case; the purpose is to establish the record.

MPI publicly states that, under section 162A of the Biosecurity Act 1993, a person or business may be entitled to compensation where MPI exercises Biosecurity Act powers and a verifiable loss results. MPI also states that ex gratia payments may be considered case-by-case where loss falls outside section 162A. This request seeks the underlying claims and payment data.

1. POULTRY CLAIMS AND PAYMENTS

• For each financial year from 1 July 2010 to the present, provide the number and aggregate value of claims, compensation applications, ex gratia requests, settlements and other payment requests made by poultry farmers, poultry growers, hatcheries, egg producers, chicken-meat producers, breeders or other poultry businesses arising from MPI action.

• For each year, separately identify: claims received; claims accepted in full; accepted in part; declined; withdrawn; unresolved; total amount claimed; total amount approved; total amount paid; and average time from receipt to final decision/payment.

• Where held, break the information down by the statutory or operational basis for the MPI action, including biosecurity response, restricted place or movement controls, destruction/culling, seizure/detention, animal welfare, food safety, compliance or enforcement action.

2. BIOSECURITY ACT SECTION 162A

• Provide the policies, manuals, delegations, assessment criteria, templates and internal guidance used by MPI to receive, assess, verify, approve, decline and pay compensation under section 162A of the Biosecurity Act 1993.

• Provide aggregate data showing the reasons claims by poultry or other primary producers were declined or reduced, including late filing, causation, mitigation, insufficient verification, statutory exclusion, valuation dispute or any other recorded reason.

• Identify the appropriation, fund, account or other source from which section 162A compensation is paid and the accounting location in MPI financial records.

3. EX GRATIA AND OTHER LOSS PAYMENTS

• Provide the number and aggregate value of ex gratia payments sought and paid to poultry operators and other primary producers where loss fell outside section 162A or another statutory compensation mechanism.

• Provide the current policy and approval pathway for an affected producer to request an ex gratia payment, including the decision-maker, required evidence, review/escalation process and source of funds.

4. FARM / BUSINESS EXIT FOLLOWING MPI ACTION

• Please provide any dataset, report, briefing, review or analysis held by MPI recording poultry farms or poultry businesses that ceased trading, exited production, lost supply contracts, permanently reduced production, entered insolvency/receivership, or otherwise ceased operating following or during an MPI biosecurity, compliance, enforcement, animal-welfare or food-safety intervention.

• If MPI does not hold a dataset capable of establishing this, please say so expressly rather than creating new information.

• Provide any MPI analysis of the financial or market consequences of regulatory or biosecurity interventions on small and medium poultry operators.

5. INDUSTRY CONCENTRATION AND MARKET STRUCTURE

• Provide reports, briefings, correspondence, risk assessments or advice held by MPI from 1 July 2010 to the present concerning consolidation, concentration, vertical integration, processor/grower dependence, loss of independent producers, barriers to entry or resilience within the New Zealand poultry sector.

• Provide any analysis considering whether MPI regulation, biosecurity requirements, compliance costs, disease response measures or compensation arrangements disproportionately affect small or medium poultry operators.

• Provide any correspondence with the Poultry Industry Association of New Zealand, Poultry Council, major processors or other industry bodies concerning those issues, subject to lawful redactions.

6. AVIAN INFLUENZA / H5 READINESS AND COMPENSATION

• Provide the current compensation and financial-support plan that would apply if commercial poultry are destroyed, movement-restricted, depopulated or otherwise economically affected by an H5 avian-influenza response.

• Identify whether section 162A compensation, Government Industry Agreement arrangements, industry levies, Crown funding, commercial insurance, self-insurance, indemnities, grants or other mechanisms would respond, and identify which party bears each class of loss.

• Provide modelling or estimates of potential compensation exposure to the Crown/MPI from a significant commercial-poultry outbreak, including any scenarios or fiscal-risk assessments held.

7. OTHER PRIMARY PRODUCERS – COMPARATIVE DATA

• For comparison, provide annual aggregate section 162A compensation and ex gratia claim data for other primary producers, including dairy, beef, sheep, deer, pigs, horticulture, forestry and fisheries/aquaculture, where the information is held in that form.

• For each sector, provide claims received, amounts claimed, amounts approved, amounts paid, amounts declined and the principal recorded reasons for decline or reduction.

8. INSURANCE / INDEMNITY / RECOVERY

• For payments identified above, state whether MPI or the Crown sought or received any insurance, indemnity, reinsurance, third-party contribution, industry contribution or other recovery.

• Identify the total recoveries by financial year and the accounting location of those recoveries.

• If compensation is paid entirely from Crown or departmental funds without insurance recovery, please identify the relevant mechanism expressly.

9. CLAIMANT PATHWAY

• Provide the current form, email address, postal address and procedural instructions by which a poultry farmer or other primary producer may lodge a compensation claim arising from MPI action.

• Identify the office that receives the claim, the office/person with delegated authority to determine it, the expected decision timeframe, any internal reconsideration process, and the external review/appeal route available after a decline or disputed valuation.

• Please identify any limitation period or deadline that MPI says applies to each claim pathway.

10. FORMAT, TRANSFER AND WITHHOLDING

• Please provide existing datasets in spreadsheet or machine-readable form where held. Personal information about individual farmers or claimants may be redacted; aggregate financial and decision data is sought.

• If any requested information is held by Treasury, another department, an industry body acting under a statutory/GIA arrangement, or another public organisation subject to the OIA, please transfer the relevant part in accordance with the Act.

• For each withholding or refusal, identify the particular information affected and the statutory ground relied upon.

Central verification question

When MPI action causes a verifiable loss to a poultry farmer or other primary producer, what compensation route exists, how often is it used, what is actually paid, what is declined, who ultimately bears the loss, and where is that expenditure and any recovery recorded?

Tracking control

Reference

FARQ-MPI-INS-003

Acknowledgment received

________________

MPI reference

________________

Statutory due date / extension

________________

Follow-up / complaint status

________________

 

Kind regards,

Tracy
Isayso.net/We Review the Crown

FARQ-MPI-INS-003 | Insurance & Compensation Evidence Track