iSAYSO
Contribute

RTC-001B-002 — FOLLOW-UP: Gene Technology, Farmer Protection, Verification, Liability and Compensation

Share on FacebookShare on XInteractive reader

 

WE REVIEW THE CROWN | isayso.net

RTC-001B-002

FOLLOW-UP FORMAL NOTICE

Gene Technology, Farmer and Grower Protection, Verification, Liability and Compensation

Date

21 September 2026

To

MBIE and Environmental Protection Authority

CC

Ministry for Primary Industries; Ministry for the Environment

Status

FOLLOW-UP – prior gene technology / farmer-protection correspondence

Purpose

Require the decision-makers to identify and stand behind the authority, evidence, verification and liability framework relied upon.

This is a follow-up. We have already raised gene-technology, farmer-protection, verification and liability issues. We now require a direct, accountable answer to the matters that remain unresolved.

We are deliberately using plain language. Farmers, growers and food producers are not abstract regulatory units. Their land, crops, animals, seed, certification, contracts and livelihoods are real property and real economic interests.

If the Crown, a regulator, a technology developer, licence holder or another authorised operator introduces or permits a product, organism, seed, pollen or other biological material capable of moving beyond an intended site, the people whose land may be affected are entitled to know the authority, the evidence, the verification, the containment controls and the financial protection that applies before loss occurs.

1. Verify the authority

1. Identify the precise enactment, provision, approval, licence, delegation or other authority relied upon for any environmental release, field use, cultivation, trial, transport or other activity capable of affecting land outside the authorised site.
2. Identify the decision-maker and the statutory preconditions that had to be satisfied before the activity could be authorised.
3. Provide the contemporaneous record showing that each material precondition was checked and satisfied.

2. Verify the scientific basis

4. Identify the precise scientific propositions relied upon to conclude that the relevant gene technology or regulated organism presents an acceptable risk.
5. Identify the underlying experiments, datasets, methodology, assumptions, limitations, uncertainty and contrary evidence considered.
6. Identify who independently reviewed or verified that scientific material, and provide the record of that verification.
7. Where no independent verification was undertaken, state that expressly and identify what was relied upon instead.

Our comparison test: Government/agency scientific conclusion versus independent scientific assessment of the same proposition, evidence, period, population and methodology. Results will be recorded as VERIFIED – MATCHES, PARTIALLY VERIFIED, DOES NOT MATCH, NOT COMPARABLE, DISPUTED, or CANNOT VERIFY FROM MATERIAL PROVIDED.

3. Our land, our food, our livelihoods

An approval granted to one person is not, by itself, an answer to consequences suffered by another. If material moves onto land belonging to someone who did not consent to it, please identify:

• who is legally responsible for preventing unintended spread;
• who must establish the source and chain of movement;
• who pays for sampling, laboratory testing and expert analysis;
• who pays for containment, remediation or destruction;
• who bears crop loss, loss of organic or other certification, lost export access, lost contracts and other measurable economic loss;
• what compensation, civil-liability, insurance, indemnity, bond or financial-assurance mechanism responds;
• how an affected farmer, grower or landowner actually lodges a claim, with whom, and within what time.

4. No assumption of consent

We do not accept that a regulatory approval given to one party amounts to consent by neighbouring landowners to bear unallocated risk or loss. If Government says otherwise, identify the precise legal authority and the compensation mechanism that protects the affected property owner.

5. Plain-language accountability

If you interfere with somebody else’s land, food production or livelihood, show the authority, show the evidence, show the verification, and show who pays when it goes wrong.

Please respond to this notice as a follow-up to the existing gene-technology and farmer-protection correspondence. Where records are held, provide or identify them. Where a matter is said not to be held, identify the agency believed to hold it and transfer or refer the matter appropriately. Where no verification record exists, please say so expressly.

Kind regards
Tracy
isayso.net | We Review the Crown

 iSAYSO.net