OFFICIAL INFORMATION REQUEST – POULTRY / PRIMARY PRODUCER LOSSES, COMPENSATION AND CLAIM OUTCOMES
OFFICIAL INFORMATION REQUEST – POULTRY / PRIMARY PRODUCER LOSSES, COMPENSATION AND CLAIM OUTCOMES
|
To |
Ministry for Primary Industries – Official Information |
|
From |
Tracy – FARQ / We Review the Crown |
|
Date |
21 September 2026 |
|
Reference |
FARQ-MPI-INS-003 |
|
Purpose |
Verify the loss, compensation, claims and payment record affecting poultry operators and other primary producers following MPI biosecurity/regulatory action. |
Request
Please provide the following information under the Official Information Act 1982. This request is directed to the financial and administrative record. It does not assume that any particular MPI intervention caused industry consolidation or that compensation was payable in every case; the purpose is to establish the record.
MPI publicly states that, under section 162A of the Biosecurity Act 1993, a person or business may be entitled to compensation where MPI exercises Biosecurity Act powers and a verifiable loss results. MPI also states that ex gratia payments may be considered case-by-case where loss falls outside section 162A. This request seeks the underlying claims and payment data.
1. POULTRY CLAIMS AND PAYMENTS
• For each financial year from 1 July 2010 to the present, provide the number and aggregate value of claims, compensation applications, ex gratia requests, settlements and other payment requests made by poultry farmers, poultry growers, hatcheries, egg producers, chicken-meat producers, breeders or other poultry businesses arising from MPI action.
• For each year, separately identify: claims received; claims accepted in full; accepted in part; declined; withdrawn; unresolved; total amount claimed; total amount approved; total amount paid; and average time from receipt to final decision/payment.
• Where held, break the information down by the statutory or operational basis for the MPI action, including biosecurity response, restricted place or movement controls, destruction/culling, seizure/detention, animal welfare, food safety, compliance or enforcement action.
2. BIOSECURITY ACT SECTION 162A
• Provide the policies, manuals, delegations, assessment criteria, templates and internal guidance used by MPI to receive, assess, verify, approve, decline and pay compensation under section 162A of the Biosecurity Act 1993.
• Provide aggregate data showing the reasons claims by poultry or other primary producers were declined or reduced, including late filing, causation, mitigation, insufficient verification, statutory exclusion, valuation dispute or any other recorded reason.
• Identify the appropriation, fund, account or other source from which section 162A compensation is paid and the accounting location in MPI financial records.
3. EX GRATIA AND OTHER LOSS PAYMENTS
• Provide the number and aggregate value of ex gratia payments sought and paid to poultry operators and other primary producers where loss fell outside section 162A or another statutory compensation mechanism.
• Provide the current policy and approval pathway for an affected producer to request an ex gratia payment, including the decision-maker, required evidence, review/escalation process and source of funds.
4. FARM / BUSINESS EXIT FOLLOWING MPI ACTION
• Please provide any dataset, report, briefing, review or analysis held by MPI recording poultry farms or poultry businesses that ceased trading, exited production, lost supply contracts, permanently reduced production, entered insolvency/receivership, or otherwise ceased operating following or during an MPI biosecurity, compliance, enforcement, animal-welfare or food-safety intervention.
• If MPI does not hold a dataset capable of establishing this, please say so expressly rather than creating new information.
• Provide any MPI analysis of the financial or market consequences of regulatory or biosecurity interventions on small and medium poultry operators.
5. INDUSTRY CONCENTRATION AND MARKET STRUCTURE
• Provide reports, briefings, correspondence, risk assessments or advice held by MPI from 1 July 2010 to the present concerning consolidation, concentration, vertical integration, processor/grower dependence, loss of independent producers, barriers to entry or resilience within the New Zealand poultry sector.
• Provide any analysis considering whether MPI regulation, biosecurity requirements, compliance costs, disease response measures or compensation arrangements disproportionately affect small or medium poultry operators.
• Provide any correspondence with the Poultry Industry Association of New Zealand, Poultry Council, major processors or other industry bodies concerning those issues, subject to lawful redactions.
6. AVIAN INFLUENZA / H5 READINESS AND COMPENSATION
• Provide the current compensation and financial-support plan that would apply if commercial poultry are destroyed, movement-restricted, depopulated or otherwise economically affected by an H5 avian-influenza response.
• Identify whether section 162A compensation, Government Industry Agreement arrangements, industry levies, Crown funding, commercial insurance, self-insurance, indemnities, grants or other mechanisms would respond, and identify which party bears each class of loss.
• Provide modelling or estimates of potential compensation exposure to the Crown/MPI from a significant commercial-poultry outbreak, including any scenarios or fiscal-risk assessments held.
7. OTHER PRIMARY PRODUCERS – COMPARATIVE DATA
• For comparison, provide annual aggregate section 162A compensation and ex gratia claim data for other primary producers, including dairy, beef, sheep, deer, pigs, horticulture, forestry and fisheries/aquaculture, where the information is held in that form.
• For each sector, provide claims received, amounts claimed, amounts approved, amounts paid, amounts declined and the principal recorded reasons for decline or reduction.
8. INSURANCE / INDEMNITY / RECOVERY
• For payments identified above, state whether MPI or the Crown sought or received any insurance, indemnity, reinsurance, third-party contribution, industry contribution or other recovery.
• Identify the total recoveries by financial year and the accounting location of those recoveries.
• If compensation is paid entirely from Crown or departmental funds without insurance recovery, please identify the relevant mechanism expressly.
9. CLAIMANT PATHWAY
• Provide the current form, email address, postal address and procedural instructions by which a poultry farmer or other primary producer may lodge a compensation claim arising from MPI action.
• Identify the office that receives the claim, the office/person with delegated authority to determine it, the expected decision timeframe, any internal reconsideration process, and the external review/appeal route available after a decline or disputed valuation.
• Please identify any limitation period or deadline that MPI says applies to each claim pathway.
10. FORMAT, TRANSFER AND WITHHOLDING
• Please provide existing datasets in spreadsheet or machine-readable form where held. Personal information about individual farmers or claimants may be redacted; aggregate financial and decision data is sought.
• If any requested information is held by Treasury, another department, an industry body acting under a statutory/GIA arrangement, or another public organisation subject to the OIA, please transfer the relevant part in accordance with the Act.
• For each withholding or refusal, identify the particular information affected and the statutory ground relied upon.
Central verification question
When MPI action causes a verifiable loss to a poultry farmer or other primary producer, what compensation route exists, how often is it used, what is actually paid, what is declined, who ultimately bears the loss, and where is that expenditure and any recovery recorded?
Tracking control
|
Reference |
FARQ-MPI-INS-003 |
|
Acknowledgment received |
________________ |
|
MPI reference |
________________ |
|
Statutory due date / extension |
________________ |
|
Follow-up / complaint status |
________________ |
Kind regards,
Tracy
Isayso.net/We Review the Crown