Official Information Act request — forensic authentication of Christchurch livestream
I request the following official information under the Official Information Act 1982.
This request does not seek a copy of the classified livestream or any graphic material. It seeks the records by which New Zealand Police verified the provenance, integrity and authenticity of the recording.
Source and provenance
Please provide the record identifying:
(a) the source from which Police first obtained the recording;
(b) the date and time it was obtained;
(c) whether Police obtained the original Facebook/Meta file, a native device recording, a downloaded copy, or some other version;
(d) every Police exhibit number assigned to the recording or recording device; and
(e) the filename, file size, format, duration, resolution, codec and cryptographic hash of every evidential version.
Recording device
Please provide the record identifying:
(a) the make, model and serial number of the recording device;
(b) where, when and by whom it was seized;
(c) its exhibit number;
(d) whether a native recording was recovered from it; and
(e) the forensic-imaging method, software and resulting hash values.
Facebook/Meta material
Please provide:
(a) the schedule of records supplied by Facebook or Meta;
(b) all non-graphic upload, streaming, account, server, timestamp, transcoding and deletion metadata;
(c) the hashes of the files supplied; and
(d) the report recording whether the Meta-supplied material matched any file recovered from the recording device.
The substantive visual content may be excluded.
Forensic authentication
Please provide every report, memorandum, worksheet or expert opinion determining:
(a) whether the recording was authentic;
(b) whether it was transmitted live;
(c) whether it had been edited, composited, re-encoded or otherwise altered;
(d) whether video frames, audio or visual elements had been inserted, removed or materially modified;
(e) the effect of compression, transcoding, dropped frames and stream latency;
(f) how its timing was reconciled with CCTV, emergency communications and other independently timed records; and
(g) the qualifications and position of each examiner.
Chain of custody
Please provide the exhibit and chain-of-custody records showing:
(a) when every version entered Police custody;
(b) every forensic copy created;
(c) every alteration in filename, format, resolution, codec or duration;
(d) every recorded integrity issue or break in continuity; and
(e) the position or unique identifier of each person who handled or examined it.
Gareth Jacobs report
A report attributed to digital forensic analyst Gareth Jacobs states that he raised concerns with Detective Inspector Chris Cahill in 2019 and supplied an earlier report.
Please provide:
(a) the correspondence and report received from Mr Jacobs;
(b) the date of receipt;
(c) the record showing where it was referred;
(d) every assessment, decision and response concerning it;
(e) the record of any testing of his assertions against the original evidential file; and
(f) if no examination occurred, the recorded reason and identity or position of the decision-maker.
Evidential reliance
Please provide the record identifying:
(a) each criminal or coronial proceeding in which Police relied upon the recording;
(b) the authentication evidence supplied to the prosecution, defence, sentencing court, Royal Commission or Coroner;
(c) whether authenticity was proved by expert evidence, formally admitted, or treated as established following the guilty pleas; and
(d) the legal or evidential basis upon which Police describe the recording as an authentic livestream.
Independent examination
Please provide any decision concerning whether an expert independent of New Zealand Police should examine the original recording.
If independent examination was declined, please provide the decision, reasons, date and position of the decision-maker.
Particular derivative file
Please state whether the following publicly identified derivative file matches any original or evidential Police-held file:
Filename: Christchurch-Mosque-Shooting-New-Zealand.ia.mp4
Reported size: 64.8 MB
Reported resolution: 648 × 360 pixels
Reported MD5: baa4fe810dc008d09ed94c17a4c35cb9
If it does not match, please identify the respects in which it differs, excluding prohibited visual content.
Withholding
If information is withheld, please identify:
(a) the document withheld by date, title, author and subject;
(b) the precise statutory ground relied upon;
(c) the particular prejudice said to arise from release;
(d) the public-interest considerations applied; and
(e) why partial release of technical data, hashes, metadata or a redacted report is not reasonably possible.
The classification of the visual content does not, without more, determine whether non-graphic technical reports, metadata, hashes, exhibit schedules and decision records may be released.
Please transfer any part of this request held more closely by another agency in accordance with s 14 of the Act and notify me of that transfer.
Please provide the records electronically in searchable form.
Preservation notice
Please preserve all records potentially responsive to this request, including forensic images, exhibit registers, hash records, audit logs, working notes, emails and correspondence with Facebook/Meta, the prosecution, defence, Classification Office, Royal Commission and Coronial Services.
Please confirm receipt, the Police reference number, and the statutory due date.
Yours faithfully,
Tracy Lynch
NOT A LAWYER