iSAYSO
Contribute

Green Stickering a car by the police. This is where we are with private plates and registration at present.

Share on FacebookShare on XInteractive reader

Here is an example,  A car was pulled over, because they knew the car was in Private Trust ownership and was displaying trust Logo identification, the plates on the car were private plates . They green stickered the car because it was not registered to NZTA and did not display the normal WOF how ever the car had been checked and was completely road worthy with a Trust Certificate of fitness. Was this a lawful stop and was green stickering the car lawful?
 

Short answer: the stop was probably lawful; the green sticker is more contestable but often still lawful under current NZ transport law. The details matter a lot though.


🚓 1. Was the stop lawful?

Under the Land Transport Act 1998, Police have very broad powers to stop vehicles.

They can stop a vehicle:

  • At any time, for enforcement purposes
  • Without needing suspicion

That includes checking:

  • Registration
  • Licensing (rego)
  • Warrant of Fitness (WoF)
  • Driver compliance

👉 So even if the reason was:

“We recognised this vehicle as a trust-owned vehicle with non-standard plates”

That still falls within:

  • Vehicle compliance enforcement
  • Identification of vehicles not properly registered

✔ Conclusion:
The stop itself was almost certainly lawful.


🚫 2. The registration issue (this is the key problem)

In New Zealand, to be used on public roads a vehicle must be:

  • Registered with Waka Kotahi NZ Transport Agency
  • Display official number plates
  • Have a valid WoF (or CoF for applicable vehicles)

👉 A private trust registration system is not recognised in NZ law for road use.

So even if:

  • The vehicle is genuinely owned by a trust
  • It is mechanically roadworthy
  • It has a “Trust Certificate of Fitness”

That does not satisfy statutory requirements.

✔ Legally, the vehicle would be treated as:

  • Unregistered
  • Unlicensed
  • Potentially unfit (in a legal sense)

🟢 3. Was the green sticker lawful?

A green sticker (notice of prohibition) is used when a vehicle is:

  • Unsafe
  • Or not compliant with legal requirements

Police can issue this if they believe the vehicle:

  • Poses a risk to safety OR
  • Is sufficiently non-compliant to justify removal from the road

⚖️ The tricky part

You’re raising an important distinction:

“The car was actually roadworthy”

That may be true mechanically — but:

👉 NZ law separates:

  • Mechanical safety
  • Legal compliance

Even if mechanically sound, a vehicle can still be:

  • Legally unsafe to operate
  • Because it is unregistered / uncertified under NZ law

✔ Likely Police justification

Police would argue:

  • No valid WoF → cannot verify safety under NZ system
  • Not registered → not traceable / accountable
  • Non-standard plates → enforcement risk

👉 That combination is usually enough to justify a green sticker.


⚠️ Where you could challenge it

A green sticker may be challengeable if:

  • The officer did not actually assess safety risk
  • They issued it purely because they disagreed with the trust system
  • The decision was unreasonable or disproportionate

🧠 Key legal issue in your situation

This is the core conflict:

Your position:

  • Vehicle is roadworthy
  • Owned under a private trust
  • Certified under a parallel system

Legal reality:

  • NZ law does not recognise alternative certification systems
  • Compliance must be through statutory regime

⚖️ NZBORA angle (possible but difficult)

You could try to argue under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990:

  • Arbitrary detention (s22)
  • Unreasonable seizure (s21)

BUT courts have consistently held:

  • Vehicle regulation is a justified limitation
  • Road safety enforcement is a strong state interest

👉 So NZBORA arguments here are not strong on their own


🧾 Bottom line

✔ The stop:

Lawful — Police can stop any vehicle for compliance

⚠️ The green sticker:

Likely lawful, because:

  • Vehicle was not registered with NZTA
  • No valid WoF under NZ law
  • Non-standard plates

Even if:

  • The vehicle was mechanically sound
  • You had a trust-based certification

👉 NZ law doesn’t currently recognise that system.


🧠 Where your strongest argument actually is

Not:

  • “The car was safe”

But:

  • Was the officer’s decision to green sticker proportionate and properly reasoned?

That’s a much narrower — but more realistic — line of challenge.